Carly Smithson- The Shadow of Your Smile
Top Comments
All Comments (144)
-
@tomflush Actually she definitely did oversing it, you need to listen to how it's supposed to be done. This song is supposed to be below a whisper!!!
-
Sang it perfect girl - you idiots who say she over sang need ear wax removal stat !
-
I think Carly should have come into the song more tender,softer, to sell the love story and then waited until the song peaked at "I" then added her beautiful soulfulness the mid and end was excellent, but the beginning started out like a rocker, not bad, but not for this song. This was a competition and the judges tell these kids to "Bring it" and I think thats all she thought about when doing this song. I'm an old jazz girl and mid and end was very refreshing.
-
Испохабила песню, ядрена вошь!
-
the talent is there, no doubt ,but for an old guy like me, this is torturing.
-
FAKE ! SHE´S SIMPLY THE WORST COVER OF AMY LEE !
RIDICULOUS !
HAVE NO TALENT AND CHARISMA !
AMY LEE IS PERFECT !
-
This left a lasting impression on me. I listen to it regularly.
-
Charming 4!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
she oversinged it. take away all the tenderness and delicacy the song supposed to have.
surawudhman 2 years ago 18
@surawudhman
Yup, she is just screaming... it sounds like she is angry. That is the problem with pop music these days, everyone just tries to shout and go high.
sdblosom 1 year ago 6