http://wonkroom.thinkprogre... On the House floor on Earth Day, April 22, 2009, Rep. Michele Bachmann (R-MN) argues that manmade global warming doesn't make any sense because "carbon dioxide is a n...
http://wonkroom.thinkprogress.org/200... On the House floor on Earth Day, April 22, 2009, Rep. Michele Bachmann (R-MN) argues that manmade global warming doesn't make any sense because "carbon dioxide is a natural byproduct of nature." Attempting to repeat the goofy denier talking point that CO2 makes up only a fraction of the atmospheric content and thus isn't of concern, Bachmann errs wildly. She claims that carbon dioxide makes up "three percent of the atmosphere," when in fact it only comprises 0.03% -- off by a factor of a hundred.
Rep. Earl Blumenauer (D-OR) responds: "Its interesting to listen to her say that something that was naturally occurring simply couldnt be harmful, ignoring the fact that we have the highest concentrations of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere for 2/3 of a million years."
BACHMANN: But people talk about cap and tax and they arent sure exactly what were talking about. Lets get back to step one. What is the problem? Why do we have to have this tax in the first place?
Its about carbon dioxide.
Well, what is carbon dioxide? Lets just go to a fundamental question.
Carbon dioxide, Mister Speaker, is a natural byproduct of nature. Carbon dioxide is natural. It occurs in Earth. It is a part of the regular lifecycle of Earth. In fact, life on planet Earth cant even exist without carbon dioxide. So necessary is it to human life, to animal life, to plant life, to the oceans, to the vegetation thats on the Earth, to the, to the fowl that — that flies in the air, we need to have carbon dioxide as part of the fundamental lifecycle of Earth.
As a matter of fact, carbon dioxide is portrayed as harmful!
But there isnt even one study that can be produced that shows carbon dioxide is a harmful gas. There isnt one such study because carbon dioxide is not a harmful gas, it is a harmless gas. Carbon dioxide is natural. It is not harmful. It is part of Earths life cycle.
And yet were being told that we have to reduce this natural substance and reduce the American standard of living to create an arbitrary reduction in something that is naturally occuring in the earth. Well were told the crux of this problem is human activity. Its humans that are creating more carbon dioxide!
Is that true, or is that false?
Well, carbon dioxide is a natural part of Earths atmosphere. The carbon dioxide is perhaps three percent of the total atmosphere thats in the Earth. So if you take a pie chart, and you have all of Earths atmosphere, carbon dioxide is perhaps three percent of that total.
What part of human activity creates carbon dioxide? If carbon dioxide is a negligible gas and its only three percent of Earths atmosphere, what part is human activity?
Human activity contributes perhaps three percent of the three percent. In other words, human activity is maybe 3 percent contributing to the 3 percent of carbon dioxide thats in Earths atmosphere. Its so negligible — its a fraction of a fraction of a fraction of a percent — that it can hardly be — be quantified.
BLUMENAUER: My good friend, the gentlelady from Minnesota, doesnt think there are any problems with the concentration of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere. Its interesting to listen to her say that something that was naturally occurring simply couldnt be harmful, ignoring the fact that we have the highest concentrations of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere for 2/3 of a million years.
The consensus of the scientific community — not people making things up on the floor of the House — is that this has been profoundly influenced by human activity, starting with the dawn of the Industrial Revolution, where we started consuming huge quantities of coal, burning fossil fuels, accelerating that over time. The consensus of the scientific community is that this is in fact a serious problem.
Like to rate videos and let people know what you think?
Automatically share your ratings, favorites, and more on Facebook, Twitter, and Google Reader with YouTube Autoshare.
Autoshare makes certain YouTube activities public on the services you choose. Select only the services you are comfortable with - like Facebook, Twitter, or Google Reader - to let your friends know what you like on YouTube. You can turn Autoshare off at any time.
Like to share videos with friends?
Automatically share your ratings, favorites, and more on Facebook, Twitter, and Google Reader with YouTube Autoshare.
Autoshare makes certain YouTube activities public on the services you choose. Select only the services you are comfortable with - like Facebook, Twitter, or Google Reader - to let your friends know what you like on YouTube. You can turn Autoshare off at any time.
...CO2 is a trace gas...the truth is that CO2 has never driven climate change, as a matter of fact, increases in CO2 comes about after a warming trend ...mainly as a a result of Solar activity.
Since people are talking 3rd grade(?) maybe it should be explained this way. A boat floating on the water has a small amount of water in it.- just enough to keep it afloat - when you put more water into the boat to the point at which it sinks deep enough to let more water in - you gotta bail like hell before it sinks totally and you drown. In other words - you better reduce the CO2 or plant a hell of a lot of trees FAST !
When are people going to see the point ? YES Carbon Dioxide is a natural component - it has nothing to do with WHAT it is but the BALANCE. Does it make any sense that the world has built a careful balance during the last 100 million years without a single human being around ? Yes ? good ? Now we have almost 9 BILLION many of whom churn out extra quantaties of CO2 that were NOT there before while at the same time we have been reducing the very trees that convert it - ergo - out of BALANCE !
it's not a personal matter. Maybe she's a great neighbor. She took a position of authority because people voted for her based on what she said... and she took that power and used it inappropriately. I hold her accountable for her actions.
But there is a disconnect between what she wants, and what means she believes will accomplish it because she has not taken into account a few factors due to her own biases and fears.
I am not at odds with God. I am not afraid of taking into consideration anybody's ideas. And I do not belong to "the other" that you lump all perspectives into that are not your own. I am not a liberal or an athiest, nor do I find any resolve in polarized simplification
That's fine. And I'm well aware of the origins of public education. And I disagree with our education system as a whole and the pedagogy geared towards obedient and efficient members of society.
I also disagree with lying. Take a poll of her hometown and see how many people voted for her further involvement in government. The fact is, she is dishonest, and didn't consider the fact that not everybody has the luxury of homeschooling their children.
Did you sane people ever think there would come a day when we would have to tell the Congress of the USA that carbon dioxide is a natural helpful component of nature?
Autoshare makes certain YouTube activities public on the services you choose. Select only the services you are comfortable with - like Facebook, Twitter, or Google Reader - to let your friends know what you like on YouTube. You can turn Autoshare off at any time.
But there is a disconnect between what she wants, and what means she believes will accomplish it because she has not taken into account a few factors due to her own biases and fears.
I am not at odds with God. I am not afraid of taking into consideration anybody's ideas. And I do not belong to "the other" that you lump all perspectives into that are not your own. I am not a liberal or an athiest, nor do I find any resolve in polarized simplification
I also disagree with lying. Take a poll of her hometown and see how many people voted for her further involvement in government. The fact is, she is dishonest, and didn't consider the fact that not everybody has the luxury of homeschooling their children.
She just didn't want to contribute.
I learned this in the third grade!