Jill Greenberg on MSNBC Scarborough Country

That guy with the mustache is abusing me with his loud voice and rude hand gestures... I want to cry...

i agree that i want to slap the guy with the moustache...
Children cry constantly when they are young, those children were given back the lollipops and in their older life they aren't going to be traumatised by one minute of crying. children sometimes react like that even when you tell them they can't have something they want. there much more open with their emotions.

what the fuck is wrong with her voice, one things its american which is bad, but its like shes had something jammed down her throat LOL !!

Listen you give me one child and I will ask it has your older sibling ever taken away a toy or candy you were holding that made you cry? They will say yes, give me 17 other children and they will say the same thing. I think she is an amazing artist and should not be pummeled by hurtful words coming out of these bloggers mouths, they are to stupid to understand and comprehand the meaning of her art.

Most of her photographes that I looked on her website are very nice, but I just don't agree with this, I could never do it myself, and I would never allow my child to be used for something like this. There are so many unhappy children in the world, it makes me happy when I see pictures of happy kids in pictures, and these ones I did not enjoy or agree with even with the point that the artist was trying to make.

that is kind of (*&*&% , abuse, I love kids, I have been working with them and I am an activist against child abuse but what is that guy talking about, I;m with the people who said "Would you have preferred that Greenberg captured photos of crying children that were in hospital's,war zones,?"
I wish he would go out of his comfort zone to  see how important it is to show the pain that our politicians make to world and kids all around the world.

I have a question for Bill Fallon - Fmr. Prosecutor. Your argument is that J.Greenbergs photos/art is exploitative of crying children, and that Greenberg is profiting off of their "abuse".

How is that any different than the income you get from your work?

Would you have preferred that Greenberg captured photos of crying children that were in hospital's,war zones,abject poverty or any number of other venues?

She induced crying based on a temporary removal of a Lollipop, which is not abusive.

I wonder if this would have been a concern for the bloggers if the photographer (Jill Greenberg) had used a different method to capture her photo's? The fact is that children (people in general do) cry for any number of reasons.
Supposed the method of capturing the image of a crying child was not "induced with the taking away of a lollipop, but instead J. Greenberg photographed children in settings where they were crying anyways? Places like hospitals,war zones,funerals that more exploitative?

I wonder what happened to Rita Crosby?

I don't mind her voice, but I guess it grates on some people. Maybe she works behind the scenes now.