Joshua Bell Concert
Loading...
Link to this comment:
Top Comments
All Comments (93)
-
these people seriously have no idea what they are talking about....unless you have a trained musical ear there is no reason to be judging Joshua Bells performance.....he is IN-tune with each note he plays here and i have only ever once heard him make a mistake at one of the many concerts I have been to, but then again I have been playing for twelve years....doesn`t mean I can play like him but can judge intonation.
-
@jhviolin29 ...you've played with Zukerman and Ma? who the hell are you...?
-
Again, every major concert artist I have ever heard plays sometimes plays out of tune. Oistrakh, Kogan, Perlman, Zukerman, Stern, Ma, etc. (Zukerman and Ma I have personally played with on a live stage).
Does Joshua Bell sometimes play out of tune as well? He sure does. Is there a quantifiable number of additional notes he plays out of tune more than the other artists I listed to which said sum can be considered a defect to his superb musicianship?
-
It seems that you're trying to mask his out-of-tunity with flash talk about musicianship and amateurs and criticism.
If the performer has musicianship then they shouldn't play out of tune.
You don't need to mask it to know that Joshua Bell is,at least, a halfway decent violinist. But in this video,he's obviously playing in tune and you can't shove a bunch of technical words on top to make it seem any better.
-
So quick!xD
-
I agree!
-
what do you mean out of tune, i mean your talking about Joshua Bell here!
-
joshua bell and andre rieu are like the best violin players in the universe!!! i saw him in california and he also plays the cello.
-
To add to it, if you DO happen to hang around YouTube at all, do something constructive. I find that posting my own videos of my violin playing creates some really lively discussions of violin that I enjoy- praise as well as constructive criticism. That to be is invaluable, as I'm currently not taking lessons and want to keep my playing level up. Otherwise, yes, get off YouTube!!!!
9:02Joshua Bell - Bruch violin concerto (movt 1)by Elfinsafety574,366 views
- 3:22Anoushka Shankar Live at Verbier Festival - Mis...by KavitaChhibber675,305 views
- 0:33Joshua Bell live in Concert 2007by dianarosssuperstar47,855 views
- 9:41Joshua Bell plays Beethoven (5/5)by Yamafuki182,922 views
- 3:27Joshua Bell - O Mio Babbino Caroby mikedonovan21401,865 views
- 0:41Joshua Bell in Czestochowa, Polandby DolceSfogatoMagazine1,063 views
- 4:19The Making of a Musician: Joshua Bellby LFLCvideos110,212 views
- 4:21Joshua Bell-Donizetti:Una furtiva lagrima (A fu...by FlorenceAshley294,884 views
- 3:41Joshua bell, Anna Netrebko for a romantic sunsetby AGMC424,676 views
- 9:31Joshua Bell plays Beethoven (4/5)by Yamafuki112,879 views
- 2:36Joshua Bell performs 'Summer' (3rd mov)by UGTownsend84,880 views
- 1:42Joshua Bell in Pittsburghby HannahCam1,546 views
- 1:09Joshua Bell and Jeremy Denk at the Paramount vi...by GatitaOhay459 views
- 2:49Joshua Bell @ Hollywood Bowlby katcho034,317 views
- 2:53Joshua Bell Apres Un Reveby sycophantv1,180 views
- 4:50Bach - Concerto for Two Violins in D Minor BWV ...by kovezett110,692 views
- 8:56Isaac Stern plays Ravel's Tziganeby aimson98,741 views
- 7:32Joshua Bell plays Liebesleid and Liebesfreudby airplanelova93259,615 views
- 4:18Joshua Bell playing Ave Maria.by airplanelova93997,639 views
Hello friends. You all seem to enjoy arguing over pointless things. My suggestion for you would be for you to get a life and stop using YouTube as a means of releasing your frustations due to your lack of any musical talent or ability whatsoever. None of you mindless critics will ever have a true understanding of music, so quit pretending like you do and keep your senseless and idiotic comments to yourself. Thanks, morons.
wsrideabike 4 years ago 6
"I must be honest, Vanessa Mae is much more on-tune and skilled than Joshua Bell. "
That anyone could think this...sad.
"He plays incredibly out of tune, especially in this video. You must be tone deaf or distracted by his body contortions."
Every violinist plays out of tune. Unfortunately, the greater the musicianship of the performer, the harsher the amateurs' criticism seems to become.
jhviolin29 3 years ago 2