What Have I Become? - Sherlock Holmes and the Case of the Silk Stocking
Uploader Comments (Eriksoneandonly)
Top Comments
-
love how this Watson doesn't allow himself to be objected to Holmes' crap :) he sticks it to the man!
i still love Holmes though!
-
I enjoyed the action of the film. Referencing canon does not make something canon. The story of the movie is in no way canon, just as the movie above that I used to make that music video is not canon. The Granada television show was considerably closer to the books themselves, containing the actual stories of the books, making them the closest canon adaptations, much closer than the new movie. Don't insult me, I don't insult you.
All Comments (82)
-
@aliveinchrist13 It's quite good, I'd recommend it.
Thank you! Yes, the emotions that Holmes expresses in this version, a world-weary pain and a loneliness, really brought this song to mind.
Thank you so much, I'm so glad you enjoyed. :) (Also, love your username! :D)
-
Hmmm. Have never seen this adaption, but I am intrigued. -trots off to google-
This is a lovely video! It never would have occurred to me to pair this two, but they seem to fit beautifully, and you are very perceptive to make such a connection.
The editing job is wonderful and very impressive.
-
wow i dedicate this 2 an old friend..... u know who u r



This is such a brilliant video. I cannot believe that I haven't seen this adaptation! Really good job, it actually brought a little tear to my eye.
SironaFlett 1 year ago
@SironaFlett Thank you so much! I'm very glad you enjoyed it. It's a surprisingly good adaptation, though not entire canon-correct. Thanks again!
Eriksoneandonly 1 year ago
you this song is actuly called hurt
werfox666 1 year ago
@werfox666 Yep, it is. The video is called What Have I Become, but the song is called Hurt. :) Thanks.
Eriksoneandonly 1 year ago
I love this video, I have had it saved to my playlists for over a year and keep watching it. Very well done - I love canon but I love this, too! Nice interpretation. =)
jamiedrilling 1 year ago
@jamiedrilling Oh, thank you so much! That's quite an honor. I'm so glad you enjoy it as much as you do. :) Yes, it's the same for me! Thanks again!
Eriksoneandonly 1 year ago