Reading LOTR: FOTR - Chapter 19 -The Mirror of Galadriel - Audiobook
Uploader Comments (PhilsStuffofDoom)
Top Comments
-
Thanks! I'm getting really addicted to this audiobook of yours. :)
-
Two cheers for philsstuffofdoom. Hip hip hooray! Hip hip hooray!
All Comments (21)
-
Thanks a lot for this reading, I wonder if there are more chapters to enjoy as I did on hearing this one. If so, please , somebody let me know.
-
@Jennifer7K wat
-
poop
-
@GreatSouthport I had a passage in the Silmarillion in mind which stated that Galadriel left Aman 'to rule a land of her own' or something. Tbh I only brought this up, because I recalled a short exchange between Galaldriel and Saruman in the Ch 'Many Partings' and I could not think of any reason for Tolkien to put that in LotR unless perhaps to contrast the differences between these two great beings coping with loss of power. Then I started lookin for similarities (sry for account name change)
-
@TheWebBat @TheWebBat I think perhaps you have misread Galadriel, I don't think she has an inherant desire to rule at all. She is very wise and powerful and indeed very ancient but nowehere is there the suggeston of a desire to rule. She has deep sorrow and carries a melancholy after a life which has seen great sadness and lamentation for those fallen and for great deeds by her kin and others combined with a sad forboding of her peoples doom and decline in light of either outcomes of the ring.
-
Frodo really was the best person to be the ring-bearer. Anyone who had any desire to gain power/use the ring, even a really good person, would have been corrupted and turned evil.
-
it's been ages since I read this, however this was my favorite chapter.
I enjoyed listening to it. Thank you :)
Loved it! Especially that you did not went for Radiocative!Galadriel, that would have been inappropriate.
Listening to the chapter I just realized a lot has been said in interpretations about the chararcter pairs of Gandalf/Saruman [Sauron] and Galadriel/Shelob, but I just noticed the similarities between Saruman and Galadriel. Both have an inherent desire to rule, great charisma and posses power over the minds of others. That makes their confrontation at the end of ROTK pretty interesting.
TheWebBat 10 months ago
@TheWebBat I too think Galadriel in the movie was a scary person, and made no sense, especially if one reads the book. Good observation!
PhilsStuffofDoom 10 months ago
Has chapter 20 been uploaded yet? or is it in working progress. I've really enjoyed listening to these. Thumbs up for PhilsStuffofDoom
ravensandlife 11 months ago
@ravensandlife I'm actually currently working on Chapter 20 (and 21), so yes, it is still a work-in-progress. Thanks for enjoying them!
PhilsStuffofDoom 11 months ago