@Kobzar3374 Sorry, but the 32nd notes in this piece are not meant to be heard as individual notes, more like a trill in the background or a continual texture throughout the providing harmony to the main theme. In this performance, it sounds lethargic rather than maestoso--"majestic"--as Rach intended in his triumphant finale to his Moments. I give her credit for her efforts, as I can attest from personal experience that it is extremely difficult piece to play.
It is a fine performance this performance is an approach that deliberately finishes knitting the sound, has the composition power very much, and with tasting of listening.
your playing is better than me.of course. im struggling to playing this piece but you sound you are the same haha...lets keep it up till we can do this perfectly ! :P
@claudemanfre Have to agree. Even for an exercise it was bad, quite a lot of mistakes and played too slowly. For some of the passages to connect properly you cant have a 10 second delay between a cadence or it just wont work.
It is a very hard piece so I cant blame her but it was a bad performance of it. Needs a lot more practice.
I personally think that this is a wonderful piece and that she plays it very well. This sounds like a hard piece and she must have practiced this piece for a very long time. ;) I have heard a few wrong note here and there but overall, beautiful job. i give this peice a four and a half star rating.
I think I should correct myself, because I have noticed some bad notes in some places, but well, everything can be improved. May be not a five stars, but a four stars rating.
Sorry if I don't agree with most of the comments posted so far about this performance. I am not a specialist, but I think that one of the best features of this version is the tempo choice. By choosing a slower tempo than most pianists, this lady achieves a higher degree of clarity, so I can hear not only the melody, but everything, all those sumptuous harmonies that in other versions get blurred and lost into a dull mess. I find this more powerful, convincing, passionate. Bravo!
@Kobzar3374 Sorry, but the 32nd notes in this piece are not meant to be heard as individual notes, more like a trill in the background or a continual texture throughout the providing harmony to the main theme. In this performance, it sounds lethargic rather than maestoso--"majestic"--as Rach intended in his triumphant finale to his Moments. I give her credit for her efforts, as I can attest from personal experience that it is extremely difficult piece to play.
speedy4500 9 months ago
It is a fine performance this performance is an approach that deliberately finishes knitting the sound, has the composition power very much, and with tasting of listening.
lendora85 11 months ago
your playing is better than me.of course. im struggling to playing this piece but you sound you are the same haha...lets keep it up till we can do this perfectly ! :P
sosodefjis00 1 year ago
very good!
i like this,
44wsgs 1 year ago
@claudemanfre Have to agree. Even for an exercise it was bad, quite a lot of mistakes and played too slowly. For some of the passages to connect properly you cant have a 10 second delay between a cadence or it just wont work.
It is a very hard piece so I cant blame her but it was a bad performance of it. Needs a lot more practice.
Meanman332 1 year ago
I personally think that this is a wonderful piece and that she plays it very well. This sounds like a hard piece and she must have practiced this piece for a very long time. ;) I have heard a few wrong note here and there but overall, beautiful job. i give this peice a four and a half star rating.
Paillonoa 2 years ago
She is interesting isn't she! Courageous woman. Nicely done. Hope you post more. Three stars.
mycatsapunk 2 years ago 2
I think I should correct myself, because I have noticed some bad notes in some places, but well, everything can be improved. May be not a five stars, but a four stars rating.
Kobzar3374 3 years ago
Sorry if I don't agree with most of the comments posted so far about this performance. I am not a specialist, but I think that one of the best features of this version is the tempo choice. By choosing a slower tempo than most pianists, this lady achieves a higher degree of clarity, so I can hear not only the melody, but everything, all those sumptuous harmonies that in other versions get blurred and lost into a dull mess. I find this more powerful, convincing, passionate. Bravo!
Kobzar3374 3 years ago 2
Very hard piece, the only problem is the tempo. All the rest is good, thanks.
MagicSkryabin 3 years ago