Celluloid Dream by The Citizen Erased [AFI Cover]
Uploader Comments (imustbeTINO)
Top Comments
-
Good cover
and also...
Your hair is fucking amazing (Y)
-
@imustbeTINO i am a huge AFI song, i have every album. and i only found this song cuz i just searched celluloid dream.. but personaly i think davey havok would be impressed with your talent, and putting your own style on it makes it unique, and your just not copying their style u put your own into it. 5 stars.
All Comments (85)
-
i dont care what pple say i like this alot u did a great job bro! plus afi sucks now but used to be the best band ever, but turned into comercialized band but i guess everyone needs to make a buck, but i miss songs like this and the art of drowning anyways just wanted to let u know u have talent and u made it ur own sound and i personally like it alot!!
-
Wow, this isn't bad at all but you sang a little bit slow than I expected to hear at first. I'm 1 of AFI fans and I think you done a pretty good job... good cover!!
btw,sorry for my bad English(I'm from Thailand)
-
you slowed it down too much mate,your just singing the words very slow.not very impressive..
-
i personaly like this alot u made it ur own and it brings out alot of emotions, great job
-
while you do sing very well and I respect the fact that you tried to do something very different with the song I just don't see this song in particular slowed down this much. I think had you done this with a song like Ever and a day I feel like it would have gone better.
that being said, had this not been an attempt at my favorite afi song I would have considered it a great song because it is rather lulling.
-
I think this is a really great cover I'm a huge AFI fan and I really love this song I think what you did with it is really different (good different)
-
ur own style is sick man i like it its different!!, screw pple who dis everything, express ur talent, i understand pple liking the original but come on u listen to oafi earlly 90s i love that style and now they sound emo, but i stuck with afi no matter what but i wont buy there new stuff lol anyways its a good twist on a different style song, good job
-
copyright infrengment asshole
-
Vocals- 2.5/5 (some of the notes are awful.. sorry :()
Cover Creativity- 4/5 (Nothing like original :) which is good... and can sometimes get bad.. in this case both)
-
i can hear some havok tones in there but youre off and that cheap reverb is annoying.
I don't mean to sound like an asshole, I just wanted to offer my feedback. I hope it will be more constructive than most of these comments.
I personally don't think you're a bad singer, I think you're actually quite good.
But I think the problem with this vid is that people watched it expecting This Celluloid Dream by AFI. I understand putting your spin on the song, but you just made it a completely different song. As far as Im concerned this isn't this celluloid dream.
But I still liked it! :D
blaqkflame 1 year ago
no no, thank you - i completely agree with you. i understand why AFI fans would be mad at it. Especially considering it's a much more punkier song than what i've done with it.
But I wanted to show it in a different light. Nonetheless, this was a year ago now, and my music style has moved on since then. Thanks for the feedback :)
imustbeTINO 1 year ago
this' my favourite of your music videos!! :)
amazing cover! you going to be touring with your album any time soon? x
amybeee3 2 years ago
oh wow, lol, i wish i was touring with it,
but i don't really make enough money off my album to go touring with it.
lol, im not really that popular
(well thats what my album sales tell me)
BUT if i ever do do a gig or tour, i'll probably tell youtube, so if you're subbed, you'll know first (Y)
I'll probably play a few songs at the tibbils gathering.
Do you have my album? xx.
imustbeTINO 2 years ago
TINO!!!!!!! omfg heyyyyyy it's Selyna!!!
haha love this vid!!!
be sure 2 tell me where I can get ur album!!!! Lurves chu lots! XD
Luxborg 3 years ago
=P you can get my album now... if you didn't know =]
imustbeTINO 2 years ago