Discussion: The Films of David Fincher

Cinema Scene's Mort and Richard Discuss the films of David Fincher. Clip from Cinema Scene Episode 69

Category:

Film & Animation

Tags:

• film
• Critics
• Cinema
• Scene
• Episode
• 69
• david
• fincher

[LookingGlassShaman]

These critics have no idea what they are talking about.

They COMPLETELY miss the point of fight club.

Neo-luddism, consumerism. Not mentioned at all.

Idiots.

[bdzbdz]

.......anyway....

WATCH ALL DAVID FINCHER MOVIES !!!

[blablaidontcarewhour]

So, they found Alien 3 to be an allegorical film about AIDS, but they failed to pick up on any of Fight Club's themes. And a critic who condemns a film because he felt squeemish (ie. Se7en) is very unprofessional.

[ZachClooney]

@imdb23 I know exactly what you mean! The correct title for this video should be GRANDADS DO THE MAKER OF FIGHT CLUB !!

[imdb23]

these people are shit stupid...

after alien 3 comes FIGHT CLUB! no wait.. Se7en! oops! TOO GORYYYYY (but in a pleasant gothic way).

these people suck!

judgemental my ass.

where the hell is "the game" in this?

[SirFreemann]

wow.... those tapes in the background were probably stolen.

Who gave them the right to critique Fincher, or any director for that matter...... clearly have no idea what they are talking about.

At least research and know about someone before you decide that a discussion on them is what's best.

[duncanpunisher]

THE GAME?!!!!!!

[futurestoryteller]

@fromdaghettowithlove

It's funny that you didn't bring that up until the things I said contradicted your beliefs... What does Tyler do with his spare time? He sells soap to luxury department stores...

And you 'mine as well'? You've been using words incorrectly like crazy. You think you understand the 'principals of Fight Club' because you fell for Tyler Durden's bullshit? That's rich. I'm ending this conversation, you're either an idiot or a lunatic, neither would surprise me.

[fromdaghettowithlove]

@futurestoryteller Space monkeys indeed. Now I could explain this all to you, but Fight Club is not about politics its about consumerism, but you wouldnt understand that...

I mine as well being talking to six year old. Come on, if you dont understand the principals of Fight Club you probably would think hes a Fascist.

[futurestoryteller]

@fromdaghettowithlove

"No, Tyler Durden is a working class hero, a slave who said no."

More like a slave who said 'I want my own slaves.' Look if you don't get it by now I'm not going to waste my time, I understand if you misunderstand, but if you're still convinced that he's right, I might as well be arguing with a six year old.

[futurestoryteller]

@fromdaghettowithlove "K for one Tyler is not an authoritan figure" You don't appear to know what that means... "hitting the bottom ground zero" Funny how you just parroted one of his propaganda slogans. " but he does not make his men go through anything he doesnt go through himself. And true, to him their existance isnt important, but neither is his own" How is this not fascist? "he is trying to help them be who they want to be" Right... Space Monkeys.

[fromdaghettowithlove]

@futurestoryteller So to boil it down, we are a generation lost to authoritan figures, and if you dont find your induviduality then you just become another stat.

Hell or nothing!!!

Fight Club is just like a support group, taken to the next level.