Nunc Dimittis (with 'Salva nos') - Gregorian Chant
Uploader Comments (catholicpeter)
Video Responses
All Comments (14)
-
@Altiar1100 In classical Latin 'c' is always a hard c. ( [k] ) For example, the word 'circa' in Latin is pronounced 'kirka', since there is no letter k. A soft c is does not exist in Latin, that is what the letter 's' is for. Ecclesiastical Latin is different.
-
I'm starting to use this in my compline hour instead of using the poor English translation the LOTH has. Thanks so much for posting this!
-
@catholicpeter Indeed, Ecclesiastical does have this pronunciation, but of course the monks would have sung in the everyday language, the Vulgate, that is, most likely, nobody really knows of course! But I do agree the language of the Holy Church would be pronounced in this way, as the Medieval Latin was an extremely complex language to pronounce, as it was differently said in the different regions, and so they chose the pronunciation in Italy as the standard, you are correct of course brother!
-
Thanks Peter. Overall it's a pretty good effort. I'm using this Nunc Dimittis for Compline :-)
By the way, "pace" should be pronounced as "pah-cheh" as opposed to "pay-say" (in the video.
Also, "principio" should be pronounced as "prin-chee-pee-yoh" as opposed to "prin-see-pee-yoh" (as in the video).
It's very subtle but you can hear the slight mispronunciation. :-)
blackchallice 1 year ago
@blackchallice That is correct, but it may be the monks German accent getting in the way. Nevertheless they have done quite well. God bless you.
catholicpeter 1 year ago
@blackchallice Incorrect my friend, in Latin, the c is indeed pronounced like an s in this case, you are thinking of Italian, the language of which came around late after the Mediaeval Vulgar Latin period, in which other European societies settled in Italy forming the new language, but perhaps that would have been said later on in the renaissance transition, who knows!
Altiar1100 1 year ago
@Altiar1100 I must disagree; the ecclesiastical Latin pronunciation of caeli or pace is to 'chay lee' and 'pa cheh'. Perhaps classical Latin has a different pronunciation in this case, which is possible.
catholicpeter 1 year ago
I have no idea what they are saying, but felt very peaceful while listening. It's beautiful!
kdsalinas1 1 year ago
@kdsalinas1 The lyrics are in the description section. It makes it even more beautiful. God Bless
catholicpeter 1 year ago