Amelia Lily sings River Deep, Mountain High with Kelly Rowland - The X Factor 2011 Live Show Finals
Top Comments
All Comments (252)
-
@aquamarine11500 Excuse me but refrain from calling me honey...and call it a day.
-
@samoanbiscuit omg what are you 12?
-
@rustytobias If you think that's what being outshone vocally sounds like, you need to have your ears, and maybe your heart replaced! Also, the word is "humility"not "humbleness". Kelly Rowland (vocally speaking) is the best judge ever. Most other singer judges wouldn't even WANT to share the stage with their protegees because they'd be vocally outshone (eg, Cheryl Cole & Alexandra Burke). Also, a big voice isn't everything, look at all the X-Factor and Idol contestants who haven't succeeded.
-
@gerip4 SO TRUE :D
-
@FamousStarhTV u obviously can't hear that well then....kelly was singing the higher harmony the whole way through!
-
@2:00-:04 such a bum note from Amelia... I love her voice but damn that was a bad note
-
@shred1224 Amelia has a bigger range but sophie had a unique tone in my opinion. its also worth noting that sophie had less screen time during the audition process, so poeple didnt get to know her as much as sophie. but I take your point :)
-
@neelay123 I disagree...I mean Sophie has a voice, but Amelia was so much better than her.
-
coz her version of billie jean was shit
-
@joecaton93 bit late but thought i'd reply. I think people need to give kelly a break. she had the most talented acts this year and it would have been hard to send any of her girls home. remember it was the producers decision to take one act away. I'm sure kelly meant what she said.
"Ever since I first saw her I knew she had something" - so why did you send her home in the first round?!
joecaton93 2 months ago 102
I don't think Amelia outshined Kelly, I think Kelly was holding back to push Amelia to do better. I mean when your on stage with someone with a voice and legacy like Kelly Rowland you have to go farther and I think Kelly wanted her to win. I think this performance was just for fun to Kelly and it was EVERYTHING to Amelia. But Their chemistry and harmony was much better than the other acts. Based on this performance she should have won. But hey, she'll get her chance now that she has the exposure
JasonRamirez1000 2 months ago 67