It's All Over/And I'm Telling You- Dreamgirls

Effie White-Nattalyee Heather Randall
Deena Jones-Lindsey Aeriel Grimble
Lorrell Robinson-Morgan WIlliams
Curtis Taylor Jr.-Sean Michael Butler
James "Thunder" Early-Christopher Roberts
C.C.-Jared Grimble
Michelle-Lynexia Owens
Frank-Mondo

Category:

Music

Tags:

• American
• Idol
• Nattalyee
• Natalie
• Lindsey
• Morgan
• Sean
• Michael
• Butler
• Dreamgirls
• Broadway
• Jennifer
• Hudson
• Beyonce
• Knowles
• Jamie
• Foxx
• Holiday

[adsweaty]

the guy in the pink bathrobe and the white girl and the white girl in the brown dress and the guy in the light brown jacket sucks at singing too who the hell had the bright idea to put white people in that play im not being rascist but a white girl cant compare to a black girls singing no offense to anybody thats my opinion and im sticking to it

[Nattalyee]

@adsweaty Thank you so much for your wonderful comment...but actually both the girls you thought were white...are actually black...they are just light skinned black girls.

[biggirlgotdreamz]

wow...she wasnt off key guys they just lowered the key thats all...(very smart if i do say so myself lol...i wish i couldve done the same when i did it for a scene)....this is a VERY hard song to do and I think you guys did wonderful!! You took a different approach to the character and made it yours, as an actress should. check out my vid when i did this on my page...it wasn't a full production and .didnt have enough singers in it but it was still pretty good considering.

[Nattalyee]

@biggirlgotdreamz Thank you very much. We actually did the whole show and this was the key given to me. You did very good in yours too.

[Pickle951]

WOW! I like the way effie played the character, most people would yel and scream at this part, but she put a softer part in this song, I likes :)!

[Nattalyee]

@Pickle951 Thank you so much...I played this a couple years ago and if I could play it again it would definately be stronger but your the first person to actually pinpoint the portrayal I was trying to give. Bravo to you.

[sealy1000]

Just to say Effie melody White you were amazing !!!!! Xxxxxxx

[GoldenEagle469]

They almost hit her!

[gennifairy]

Wow. Effie is damn awesome:)

[ajmuso]

This is amazing! And it's so refreshing to see this take on Effie! =D

[misswager36]

i love this argument

[shaaronie]

Excellent singing but like someone else said the blocking was distracting but that's the director's fault. The actors were FABULOUS! I really enjoyed it tremendously!

[16ondablack]

yall really shud have done yall homwork very poor

[adsweaty]

@beenn15 actually im not black and i do believe that most black singers ive hed have a strong good fllowing voice than white people who tend to have softer voices im white so i would just say im not being rascist im just sayin just that the 2 girls other than effie sounded really oft im not being rascit, and im just saying most of the time you can tell a diffrence, look im not going to start an arguement over this

[beenn15]

@adsweaty that's the problem with a some black people...they always see color everywhere.

[CircusDork123]

I love how ghetto fabulous Lorrell is. It put a huge smile on my face :) Lorrel was obviously going to whoop Effies ass. This was such a great version ! They were all such beautiful singers. Go on' ya'll !