53 Years Old Night Club Scene At Bombay! - Beliya Beliya, Pemiya Femiya - Parvarish [1958]
Uploader Comments (yuanyuanyuanyin)
All Comments (45)
-
@bdgogia - Thank you my dear friend for the "clarification". She is, as we too have concluded months back, Kuldip Kaur.
With regard to "appointment" of a committee, that was the wish of our friends at the time when there was an "ambiguity" on determining the identity.
No my dear friend, I am not offended at all. In fact, this is fun writing to friend like YOU. After all, we all have something important in common, that is " we all love Hindustani Music"!
May God bless you and take care.
-
@yuanyuanyuanyin This time no such thing was implicit - the dancer is Kuldip Kaur -
she was quite famous in 50s in vamp roles - but she was not Motilal's wife - neither your English is under question nor understanding me - what I found surprising was appointing a committee to determine the identity of a well-known person - you seem to have taken offence when it was not meant or implied - hope you overlook the episode - you are doing good service to listeners which fact remains. Do you agree ?
-
@bdgogia - OMG, Either I don't understand you or the English you have written! LOL
Now please tell me.
WHO IS THE DANCER?
Please reply.
Thank you.
-
@yuanyuanyuanyin big "controversy" , "mysterious dancer" and committee appointed by the friendly viewers...settled...Kuldeep Kaur..."democratic process" sound strange as Kuldip Kaur was not dancer ... watch her in vamp roles in Anarkali, Samadhi and Nau Bahar ! That she was Motlal's wife is such news which seems far fetched - but none of this is criticism of anyone - democracy means freedom of speech also !
-
@bdgogia - Thank you my dear friend for the reconfirmation.
Yes, there was a little confusion over the dancer but now everything is settled and you too have "concreted" the "collective conclusion"!
Thank you again and take care.
-
There is needless confusion - dancer in Parvarish is Kuldip Kaur - and Sheila Vaaz is the vivacious dancer in CID - Leke pehla pehla pyar ! She was also in Tumsa Nahin Dekha (l959) and Shree 420 (Ramaiya Wasta Waiya) !
-
The problem with Rajkapoor he never had his Originality. He miserably failed in trying to imitate Charlie chaplin and ended up with some half-baked style of nothing.
Shammi, on other hand, after Tumse nahin dekha, just got of his own style.
In Kapoor Family, as per my opinion, only Prithiviraj and shammi made mark. Raj as I told, was charmless in screen with his half baked charlie chaplin antics.
-
@RealMusicKing - There was a big "controversy" over this "mysterious dancer"!
In fact, there was a "committee" appointed by the friendly viewers and they came out with names and finally we all settled down to the name of Kuldeep Kaur.
Real "democratic process", I must say!
thanks for uploading the complete version of this fantastic song. I watched it many times & i visit your page regularly.
nayanmalig 11 months ago
@nayanmalig - You are most welcome, my dear friend.
Hope you will find many original Hindi songs for many of OUR local songs.
yuanyuanyuanyin 11 months ago