Palästinalied (20 Bands - 1 Lied) 1/4

Alle 13 Strophen des Palästinalieds von Walther von der Vogelweide und 2 Strophen aus der Carmina Burana, aufgenommen von insgesamt 20 Bands.

Ich habe keinerlei Rechte an der Musik bzw. an den Bildern. Auf Verlangen der Rechteinhaber werde ich dieses Video sofort löschen.

1 Musiktheater Dingo
2 van Langen
3 Mediaeval Baebes
4 Engelsstaub
5 van Langen Project
6 Galahad
7 Saltarello
8 Shadowland
9 Finisterra

Category:

Music

Tags:

• Palästinalied
• Walther
• von
• der
• Vogelweide
• Musiktheater
• Dingo
• Van
• Langen
• Project
• Mediaeval
• Baebes
• Engelsstaub
• Galahad
• Saltarello
• Shadowland
• Finisterra

[dingomusiktheater]

Oh super, jetzt mit Untertiteln, wer wann singt. Super!

[XwendigoX]

Grüße. Der Herr heisst "van Langen".

[frenchiecocorico1]

@Lebkoang2009 signed

The lout of the german medieval music.

[frenchiecocorico1]

@Lebkoang2009 "they had no adequate notation. Neumes, for example" I looked for the book by musicologist Mertens but i found only the book "Lierberspaare des Mittelalters" by Volker Mertens. Unfortunately this book isn't available to be consulted on Books Google. Though, in another of his book, he wrote about Hildegarde von Bingen (1098-1172). Could you explain me how today we know and can perform numerous of her works with the inadequate neumatic notation such an anonymous composer used ?

[frenchiecocorico1]

@Lebkoang2009 "You can now respond to the public" I answered your comments because you called me out. Why must reply to the public when it doesn't ask me nothing ? You can be more ill mannered because you prove again to be thoughless.

[Lebkoang2009]

III

You can now respond to the public. I'm interrested no longer at your answer. I'm not used to such ill-mannered people free to discuss.

[Lebkoang2009]

II

The music by WVDV is either inspired by Rudel or antiphon, or both. Whether it is at all of him is not known. Neither Rudel nor WVDV say the music is just by themselves in total. WVDV claimed nothing!!! Without claim, there is only a copy or inspiration.

You understand therefore not what is plagiarism.

[Lebkoang2009]

Now these are my last comments. I'll stop arguing with you, because you have no manners. Sorry, but you're a lout.

The musicologist Mertens showed the evident similarity of Rudel work with the antiphon. Google books.

bye

[frenchiecocorico1]

@Lebkoang2009 Yes That's a stupid assertion because their notation was sufficient to be read and transcribed nowadays. More, the neumes disappeared in the 10th and 11th centuries when the stave was created by Guy d'Arezzo (see Messine notation). Neumatic notation isn't legible due to the lack of linemark for the note pitch but it had yet time note values (porrectus, scandicus, torculus,...). This imperfection was fulfilled by the invention of the first linemarks of the stave from the year 1000

[Lebkoang2009]

"Stupid assertion"!:-(

You are absolutely insulting.

And you will not read correctly. I did not say they had no notation, I said that they had no adequate notation. Neumes, for example, "are not an adequate notation.

Most of the compositions of the time have no information on timing, rhythm, or phrasing, or instrumentation. The rhythm, we can usually only be inferred from the words. Therefore not adequate notation. All we perform is pure fantasy in this regard.