Temporary Marriage is HARAM (explained by Former Shia) PART1

Refuting Temporary Marriage. Explained in great detail

Category:

Education

Tags:

• mutah

[Zakah1]

made a minor mistake on the video where I said Rajm for adultery and fornication was abrogated, rather it was only abrogated for fornication not for adultery (as it says in the Torah that both fornication and adultery are punished by stoning, but this was abrogated and now only adultery is punished by stoning and fornication by 100 lashes)

[shanokhala]

Just show where the command of abrogation came, no heresy please .Show proof of abrogation.Same word Mutah.

We know there is a differnce, it is when the word of Mutah is contested.

[Zakah1]

@shanokhala

watch the rest of the video, Ali (ra), Ibn Omar (ra), Sabra al-juhanni (ra), Ayeshah (ra) and many others said that it was abrogated

the abrogation came from the Prophet (saw) himself who originally allowed it

also verse 24 of Surah al-Nisa has nothing to do with temporary marriage as explained on the video

[shorty40merza]

@SMLIPRT marrying my sister is not something in my hand its between you and her,, her father has guardianship over her if she is not Rashida and mut3a is for people who believe in it not people who believe its haraam and also mut3a is when your conditions force you to not stay together permanently or for people to use it as an engagement or tahreem but decent girls want only one man so they dont divorce or go into mut3a just for sampling or playing . you can do mut3a with corrupted girls

[SMLIPRT]

@shorty40merza Would you allow me to Muta your sister for the long weekend? Money is not an issue, just name your price. If things go smooth, i'll come back for more. Who needs marriage or polygamy when right...Hey don't be mad at me, its your belief. If you find it offensive, don't hate me, hate the ones that taught you these things.

[Hafez21hafez21]

You are a disgrace to the Iranian race , you have before your name that you are Sayed, well so am I, and if you are really a Seyed you have disgraced the family of the prophet. Is the money worth it?! YOU ARE ACTUALLY DEFENDING BIN LADAN????

[shanokhala]

Just show where the command of abrogation came, no heresy please .Show proof of abrogation.

[DefendDeen]

@shorty40merza Brother I posted a video on the sunnah of yellow sandals from your books made by a brother. It has chains too. watch?v=FE1aAMGBHV4 If you inviting me to not control myself, and freely do muta then you should bring full proof. As for positions, if you can't meet the demands then don't tell me muta is halaal until you can prove Imam Ali (as) allowed it from Sunni books. I want to see the full chain here. The 12th Imam did not appoint you, therefore I can disagree with you.

[shorty40merza]

@DefendDeen sorry I don't know what they mean by black sandal giving them organism, and I dont have information or knowledge about this hadeeth and its content, I dont deny Ilm Alrijal is important but here we are not in a position to study the chain that Tabary brought in his Tafseer so I just mentioned the names of the rijal of the chain. you need to watch the documentary I made and comment on that just type in search " temporary marriage in sunnie saheeh books" 4 parts

[DefendDeen]

@shorty40merza Brother, a chain narration is important. I mean in your own books there is ahadith which states don't wear black sandals, and to wear yellow ones because it gives you an organism. Guess what Shaykh Saduq attributed it to Imam Sadeq (as). Also on top of that there are mullahs in Iran wearing yellow sandals. Can you now see why Ilm-e-rijal is important ? If you cannot provide a chain then you are just copying and pasting.