Obi's Little White Lie

"Only Imperial Storm Troopers are so precise."

Category:

Comedy

Tags:

• Obi Wan
• Storm Troopers
• Obi's Lie
• Obi Wan's Lie
• White Lie
• Star Wars
• Sand People

[SloganYams]

This video deserves a LOT more views.

[boltyjr]

Funniest thing I've seen today. But it's still early. :-)

[stupidguyx]

This is hilarious.

Sand people for the win

[MachariusXXI]

Clear proof that Obi-Wan went senile with age and seclusion on Tatooine.

[Perion]

@MsPhysics22100 Your problem is that you have convinced yourself that you are right and choose to misinterpret everything I, Lucas, and the films/novels say as whatever you please. Ignoring Non-ambiguous evidence if they contradict your interpretation of ambiguous evidence, as well as insisting that your interpretation is correct.

On top of that you refuse to accept that I have no more interest in trying to reason with you about this, but you seem obsessed with attempting to force the issue.

[MsPhysics22100]

@Perion Funny because your very first comments were about how you knew for certain. Now after I showed you that George Lucas, the script, and the book as well as other evidence shows that you are wrong you change your story to

"Well there is no way to know for sure"

Just like in the other comments you realized you are wrong but refuse to man up

Oh and to answer a previous question of yours Killing them would let them get the Death Star plans back which is what they wanted

[Perion]

@MsPhysics22100 As a result, because you cannot prove that the plan was NOT in place during the firefight shown, Obi-Wan is not necessarily lying at all.

In any case, we've been going over in circles like this for quite some time, and I've noticed you going on like a broken record bringing little if anything new or relevant. As a result I feel little inclination to continue this if all you are going to do is misunderstand and talk about trivia you think I overlooked as if it had any impact.

[Perion]

@MsPhysics22100 There is indeed no way to know for certain, which is why it is entirely possible that they had it implemented before the firefight shown here, you try to maintain that they could not have, which is not something you can prove (As the Stardestroyer site says). I will freely admit that my theories are purely speculation the only reason I, but they are in line with all available evidence including Obi-Wan's assertion of Stormtroopers being precise, It's all about Parsimony.

[Perion]

@MsPhysics22100 I never said Vader KNEW their intentions, only that he predicted what they would do. Also as I said It's entire possible that they had Leia's status present in relatively low security, so there was no reason to assume they NEEDED R2 to access them (beyond R2 being the most efficient manner to do so). No proof exists that Vader didn't rescind the order, there are implications to say he did.

Again if Tarkin IS surprised it's only by the fact that they took the bait.

[MsPhysics22100]

@Perion I was curious about where you got this crazy idea of yours about them missing on purpose and I found it. From Stardestroyer website the author of it came up with the idea. However his point is more like mine where he states THERE IS NO WAY YOU CAN FIGURE OUT WHEN THE ORDER TO LET THEM GO IS STATED.

Once again you decide to not read full articles

[MsPhysics22100]

@Perion for the millionth time it is NOT IRRELEVANT! There is no way in hell Vader can know their intentions. Second they weren't easily accessed as we have seen through out ALL of the movies R2D2 is a master slicer they make a point of this. Also Vader NEVER rescends the order. That never happens.

Now George Lucas wrote in the Script and the Book that Tarkin is NOT asking a question. Tarkin is suprised that is 100% G-Canon you can't decide to ignore G-canon.