Christina Aguilera & Julie Andrews-When you wish upon a star
Uploader Comments (realmynix)
All Comments (69)
-
Julie sings like a white Grandma, Christina sings like a freak in a bad way
-
from a musician's standpoint, they are both very tallented. Christina has a edgier, rocker-esque voice that makes her stand out and as a result its seems a it showy. Julie on the other hand has a softer, sweeter, more melodic voice that is better suited to this song
-
I honestly think they're both wonderful!
-
As my mom used to say of Christina, she isn't singing, she's yelling.
-
Julie and thats all im saying! :D
-
@RontschDaPontsch Agreed, their styles are too different to compare. they both make the song their own and they both do the song great justice. Neither singer is better than the other and both are to be respected.
-
As much as I like Christina, Mrs Andrews sings this song better, without such fuss as Christina...
-
Christina is amazing, but Julie truly is a legend. I really dont think you cant compare them..they have such different styles...to compare them is just wrong!
-
Christina is vocally so much better!! She is one of the best singer on the planet.. After Mariah, Whitney and Celine (number one) <3
-
They are both very good singers, but they have different styles... so there
Why are you even comparing them? Of course Julie is the better singer! Julie is a legend! Christina is just one of those common singers. As DarlingJulie10135 said its like comparing a "fine wine with a cheap beer." Julie Andrews was amazing and will never be forgotten!
MysteriousNights 2 years ago 2
Of course Julie is amazing that's why I like her, but I think Christina is not a common singer and never will be as she has beautiful voice. In my eyes they are both wine's and the best.,
mynix
realmynix 2 years ago 20
I can't understand why people don't like Christina!? She is one of the best singers in our time. Her voice is fantastic!
Of course Julie is a legend but come on Christina can sing.,
mynix
realmynix 2 years ago 24