Re; DEFENDING THE ELLIOTT ARGUMENT PT1(1/2)
Uploader Comments (dechha1981)
Top Comments
-
Wow. That IS sad.
-
Oh, yes... Mr. AK. Making the rounds. The thing is with this poor fool is that, unlike VFX or Shockofgod or Neph, NO ONE agrees with him. NO ONE other that Chad Elliot has EVER used "the elliot argument". None of his videos have comments from people agreeing with him in any way. That's with him screening them too, so the really good comments don't see the light of day.
All Comments (49)
-
@dechha1981 I still don't get how you don't understand how simple what I'm saying is. Look up the definition of atheism in various dictionaries. Get that, dictionary, dictionary. It isn't what I think it is. If you say up means down but it really doesn't then that is your mistake whether you know it or not. But everyone else does know it. On my second point maybe you are an atheist who gets no persuasion from proof in science, which is perhaps your bias, unscientific bias (my initial point).
-
@dechha1981 1st off.. I meant to say what I think he is getting at, not definitely.
2nd, I don't know what strawman means.
3rd, my response speaks for itself. Every part, just takes some thought to...
-
Can I just give a simplified version of what the AK is trying to get at..
In its simplest, most common, accepted and understood terms "atheism" means you believe in no god; as shown in I'm guessing every legitimate dictionary, but definitely most. That is the reason he directs his argument to atheists and not agnostics. If you have a problem with the definition of atheism then have the dictionary changed, call yourself agnostic or agree with his argument. I think the other half of what is...
-
The guy giving the Elliot argument monitors all comments put on his videos. Twat. He got owned by UKatheist too.
@dechha1981 And do me a favor and please stop trying to verbally hurt me. It isn't working; and that is only straying from my point. And don't assume my position on anything..I've never gave any hint to what I believe bout the topic. Stick to what I'm saying. I said something, if you reply to me, reply to what I say and don't try to make me look stupid. I didn't come here for a fight. Not to be mean but I honestly think you'd understand that if you understood what I was saying in the first place
garDmalF 3 weeks ago
@garDmalF
"And do me a favor and please stop trying to verbally hurt me"
Oh grow up, baby. I ALREADY FUCKING TOLD YOU I don't like it when Theists tell me what I think. Do that ONE MORE TIME and you're blocked.
Oh, and you weren't saying what you meant? That's wasting my time, then. I don't have much tollerance for people who waste my time, either.
dechha1981 3 weeks ago
...put two and two together. Physics tries to explain how everything in the cosmos works..its science (fyi). Yeah it has a lot to do with the entire creator debate.
4th, what's with the attitude?
garDmalF 3 weeks ago
@garDmalF
I told you, I don't like it when Theists try to tell me wyhat an Atheist is. And again, what the fuck has that got to do with atheism? Do you get all of YOUR beliefs from...
...that's it, isn't it? To Right-wing christinas, religion, morality, creationism and politics are all the same damn thing. Therefore, you think all of out beliefs come from a single thing and you think the word "Atheism" also covers Science. Is that it? Does your entire brain come from one thing?
dechha1981 3 weeks ago
...implied is that atheism is "(insert everything said)" because physics isn't finished yet. Theoretical physicists are still working on trying to explain the 96% of the cosmos that is currently undefined, which is currently at string theory and its variants. Thus atheism should be no more credible than religion because it tries to reach beyond science, more specifically what it currently says. Thus saying that a god or uc most definitely does not exist is nothing more than a biased belief.
garDmalF 3 weeks ago
@garDmalF
That's a strawman and you know it.
You'd be suprised how many Atheist's pet peeve is "Telling me what I think". Including me. If you want to hear your own neck snap, telling an Atheist how Atheists think is a good way to make that happen.
And what the FUCK has a lack of belief in a god or gods got to do with physics? I bet you think Evolution has something to do with Abiogenesis or planets, don't you?
dechha1981 3 weeks ago