Stock/Chicago - Reznicek: Donna Diana Overture
Uploader Comments (2ndviolinist)
Video Responses
All Comments (20)
-
Super! The tempi is similar to Karajan/VPO.
-
@analogyman I don't know, I've been listening to all these version, and it seems to me that the Challenge of the Yukon version had a kind of weird syncopation that these versions don't have. Also I don't think it was quite this fast, but of course they only ever played the first 30 to 45 seconds. Until I finally found the original piece I'd made up in my head how the rest would probably go. LOL. I still think it's one of the most heroic pieces of music I've ever heard,
-
This tempo seems RIGHT to me - but then I grew up on the "Sgt. Preston of the Yukon" radio program, which had the same tempo. All others on YouTube seem to draaaaaaaaaaag out.
-
Splendid. Just splendid.
-
This has to be one of the most difficult overtures of the orchestral repertoire with the presto being placed in 3/16 - an absolute nightmare to read and must produce groans from any orchestra when told they are to play it. Shame on Reznicek for not putting it into 6/8. Superb overture, though.
Damn that's fast!
NelsonStJames 3 months ago
@NelsonStJames Also accurate and well played.
2ndviolinist 3 months ago
For jueprivat and 2ndviolinist I'd say that Stock takes a cut in the score, not uncommon in that era. I didn't do an "A/B" comparison, though.
presbyterosBassI 9 months ago
@presbyterosBassI Don't know, you may be right. We're just fortunate to have the recording in whatever form.
2ndviolinist 9 months ago
I'd say much too fast !!! normally this piece takes 6 minutes !!!
Please check the velocity of your recorder (player)
jueprivat 1 year ago
@jueprivat Pitch is correct. The Blech/Berlin Phil version is just over 4 min. Maybe a repeat not taken.
2ndviolinist 1 year ago