蘇慧倫 我不是一個人住 MTV

蘇慧倫 我不是一個人住 MTV (1994 年無線電視版本)/ 編導: 袁劍偉/作曲: 李宗盛/填詞: 周禮茂

Category:

Music

Tags:

• 蘇慧倫
• 我不是一個人住

[donask2009]

80-95年代, 真令人懷念

[tactuziz]

耐聽的一首歌. 我偏好國語歌, 可偏偏這首歌蘇慧倫唱的粵語版比較好. 首先, 歌詞方面, 粵語版的詞鏗鏘流暢, 且耐人尋味. 要是說粵語版的詞具專業水平, 那國語版的詞只有國二水平. 吊詭的是從演唱技巧上來說, 若說國語版是專業水準, 那麼粵語版只有業餘水平, 卻又反過來是粵語版的好聽耐聽, 就是因為蘇慧倫國語演唱技巧成熟到位, 反而唱太死了, 而她不懂廣東話, 唱起來少了花俏技巧, 反而更清亮純粹樸質, 更貼合歌意. 只可惜發音不正, 總還是瑕疵, 就是這一點瑕庛, 粵語版在粵語區紅不透.

[ztonely]

以前既歌就係單純既好聽、直接，旋律簡潔幽美，現代既流行曲大部­份唔係過於抄襲就係 好多花臣好複雜

[aw05172001]

知不知為什麼會比較好聽?因為她唱廣東話的共鳴跟國語的共鳴完全­不一樣,而且詞比較流露

[heuandycheung]

好耐無聽,一位臺灣歌手能唱出粵語,無論唱腔聲綫,唱出感情,都­係一流,百聽不厭

[wangkicheng]

百聽不厭:)

[kelvinc8]

When i first heard her song as a kid in HK, i was totally stunned by her sweet and lovely voice and fell in love with her right away. No HK female artists have such an effect on me, from the past to present, like this girl from Taiwan. I love her style of cantonese, so sweet!!

[apfc]

She is my vegetable and cup of tea.

[lovelikeedisonchen]

佢絕對係我女神！



[jimothy1106]

@mv27 你拎佢同果班野比???

[SugarKatie]

@tactuziz my thoughts exactly. In general, cantonese songs tend to have a better lyrical flow and literary content than mandarin songs, which are quite insipid and mediocre when it comes to content and aesthetics of words. The originals aren't necessarily better than adaptations.

[Phil28168]

我很喜欢这首歌曲。苏慧伦，你好靓！人靓声甜。你唱出这首歌曲的­广东话真的不错。