Paul vs. Feyd
Top Comments
All Comments (515)
-
the actors are all waterfat
-
@DarthRushy Oh, and some quotes here are also really good like Mohiam and Shaddam, but the Fremen look like Qizarate too early.
-
@zyxlamonde I think I semi-agree. Both miniseries and movie had good and bad parts. This scene is still better in movie though. Oddly enough, the Guild are very strange in both. In Lynch movie, the Guild are some robotic individuals with microphones and giant Navigators while here, they have odd hats and pointless gestures.
Both versions need some changes to fit with the book better.
-
Personally, I think both the miniseries and movie had their good parts. This scene, I think was better done in Lynch's movie. However, Shaddam's miniseries version along with the miniseries Baron Harkonnen was more book like(Shaddam from movie was just as great but not book like while Baron Harkonnen was a bit too gross).
-
@MrReded69 I think they liked him because he had orange hair.
-
I don't know why people like Sting's version of Feyd Ruatha instead of Matt Keeslar.Keeslar(which is a good villain name all by itself)was a complete character while Sting just posed in a rubber Hawk wing bikini(fan service)for no real reason,carried around a anorexic cat in a cage and hissed and screamed a few lines('I will kill him!").The Lynch fight scene was more film editing than fight work.The mini's fight scene was better(as when the word cousin stuns Feyd).
-
Ok seriously, what the hell is up with the hand gestures starting at 0:42? It's like watching an attempt at out acting William Shatner or some bad high school milking the giant cow crap acting.
And the fight in this version sucked period. At least Sting as Feyd in the 1984 version had some charisma and was badass.
-
This is not how they fought in the book . . . fuck this exaggerates majorly,
-
They raped dune and make it into a faggot fest.
-
@xombimonkey The little girl was trying to hold it in. If you look closely you can see it.
All I know is that I found Julie Cox as 'Princess Irulan' scrumptous!! Yes indeed
pme1967 5 months ago 7
The costumes are absurd, but I like the tone of the sets (particularly Arakeen) and desert a lot better than David Lynch's. His Dune world was just grim and unpleasant. And this fight is far superior to the poorly paced ring around the rosies that was at the end of the Lynch version. Also, the soundtracks in both the miniseries are monumentally better than the one in the Lynch film.
Myrthmor 6 months ago 5