Alert icon
We're changing our privacy policy. This stuff matters.  Learn more  Dismiss

The Unbroken Rib: Fall of a Lie, Fall of an Ideology. [1/5]

Loading...

Sign in or sign up now!
Alert icon
Upgrade to the latest Flash Player for improved playback performance. Upgrade now or more info.
16,693
Loading...
Alert icon
Sign in or sign up now!
Alert icon

Uploaded by on Oct 16, 2010

The Unbroken Rib: Fall of a lie, Fall of an Ideology.

HQ:
http://www.4shared.com/video/VmCN6IMO/the_unbroken_ribs_HQ.html

MQ:
http://www.4shared.com/video/0-epiGa8/the_unbroken_ribs_MQ.html

LQ:
http://www.4shared.com/video/mcSGzqua/the_unbroken_ribs_LQ.html

Direct Link (FTP):
http://realitymedia.ws/unbrokenribs

---------

The Turban: Opium of the Safavids.

HQ:
http://www.4shared.com/video/qdj0uESF/The_Turban_mpg_HQ.html

MQ:
http://www.4shared.com/video/xzg19S8j/The_Turban_mpg_MQ.html

--------

Shi'ism Conspiracy: Mut'ah.

HQ:
http://www.4shared.com/video/925KIQiJ/Mut3ah_film_full_version_HQ.html

MQ:
http://www.4shared.com/video/v0fX0SRh/Mut3ah_film_full_version_MQ.html

Direct Link (FTP):
http://realitymedia.ws/muttahexposed/

--------------------------
Academical refutation of the myth of the broken rib:

Refutation of all those (UNAUTHENTIC) narrations quoted by the Rafidah to prove this myth (as done by the Zindiq Yasir Alkhabith):

http://www.box.net/shared/s7khbr908k


More refutations: http://www.ahlalhdeeth.com/vbe/showthread.php?p=18587


Recently many Rawafid (mostly converts) started to deny the bitter fact that Ali (RA) did indeed marry HIS and FATIMAS (RA) daughter Ummu Kulthum to Omar (RA). They come up with weird explanation to twist the truth. But who is a bigger Hujjah/proof on them than one of their biggest Marjas/Ayatollahs of the last century?

Ayatollah Khoie says: Yes, according to the traditions and our narrations Ali (RA) gave his DAUGHTER to Omar (RA).

Link of Ayatollah Khoies website and Fatwa: http://www.alrad.net/hiwar/olama/kho2i/k09.JPG


The story of the assault on Fatima (RA), the burning of her house, and the murder of her fetus is not supported by a prophetic narration or by an authentic historical story. Logic and common sense rejects this story at all costs. Most of the sources Raafidha are mentioned are either absolutely unknown, or contain lots of unauthentic reports. Get used to the fact that a report doesn't become authentic just because some historian wrote it!

Let us assume for the moment that Abu Bakr and Omar bin Al-khattab really committed that heinous crime. But what about Ali bin Abi Talib? How could Ali stay quiet while his wife is beaten, his house is assaulted, and his son is killed? Is this the portrait of Ali bin Abi Talib that the Shia are trying to paint? The least man in faith, chivalry, and manhood will not allow his wife to be beaten. Then how come when the woman is the daughter of the Prophet peace be upon him and the man is the mighty Ali bin Abi Talib?

This is the result of the fabrication in history that became one of the tenets of faith for the Shia.

Ayatollah Al-Sayyed Hussain FadlAllah, the grand Shia scholar in Lebanon, stated clearly that he does not approve this accident to be true, he heavely doubts the assault on Fatima. Hence, lots of Shia scholars waged a war on him. They charged him with "Wahhabisim". One of the grand Shia scholars in Iran Al-Tabrizi had issued a verdict excommunicating FadlAllah from Shiasim because FadlAllah had doubted (till his very death) one of the major religious beliefs of the Shia.

FadlAllah's doubts had come after extensive research in the Shia's version of the story of the assault and he depended much on logic and common sense.

So not Only Muslims/Sunnah reject this fairy tale but even logical thinking Shias themselves!

if your grand Ayatollah can deny this event and say it did not happen do you think you can convince us to believe in this fairytale? (let alone that hussein aal kashif al-ghita and also Ayatollah almaiad from iraq and from the classical ones sheikh mufeed didn't mention this incident in any of his authentic books. kashif al-ghita said that for him this incident is highly implausible as he said:

ولكن قضية الزهراء ، ولطم خدها مما لا يكاد يقبله وجداني ، ويتقبله عقلي ، ويقنع به مشاعري ، لا لأن القوم يتحرجون ويتورعون من هذه الجرأة العظيمة ، بل لأن السجايا العربية ، والتقاليد الجاهلية

book jannat al-mawa page 81)

To watch Ayatollah Fadlullahs opinion and a lenghty refutation of this myth than click on this link here:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Er0qHW0nweY

Link to this comment:

Share to:

Top Comments

  • @asad1871 if shias would stop listening to imams and read the qor'an they would become sunni...

  • Naothubillah.. May Allaah protect me and my beloved ones, from all these shia and all of those that are related to it.

see all

All Comments (404)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • @berjaoui0 If anything.. It is closing the gap between Ahl al Sunnah and the Ahl al Bayt mazhabs.. I look at this as a plus. :)

  • I do not see how this makes the Jafari school look bad? If even our Marja's and learnt men are saying these have been fabricated ... This is actually a plus for us! You have one of the most imminent Shia Marja's (Fadlallah) denying the authenticity of such reports.. Just like Ahl al sunnah have many fabricated hadiths attributed to them. I'm sure there is Aleems and Shiehks from you Mazhabs that deny them.

    I don't understand the point of this .... If you're trying to stir strife or what.

  • @1977hero ur grandfather is a terrorist.

    the qor'an orders us to fight the koffar, while the shias join the koffar in the fight against the qor'an. ur the terrorist with ur imams and leaders.

  • sunnism is the most illogical, hypocritical, arrogant, ignorant, stupid, cruel, barbaric, deceiving cult in the world!!

  • 1:30 humble towards the other beleivers? show me who was humble except imam Ali (as) all other 3 were power hungry and blood thirsty.... if imam Ali was power hungry he would have taken advantage of martyrdom of fatima (as) and claimed caliphate.. but he never used his sword but used patience as taught by Allah and his prophet.

  • @khalilrabee if sunni can understand the quran the way it shud be they wont be terrorists..

  • @MAFHHZB Lol yep but under umar faruq ra khilafah how far did islam spread?for if he ran from one battle then.......to conquer all arabia persia romans u need plenty plenty battles but under umer faruq ra they were won and most of them battles he was at the front!

  • @shaanhaider I have read the Qur'an very carefully and yet I find no proof any of the typical Shia practices are Qur'an based

  • This ist a propaganda film.... you wahabi sekt are like nazis...... and everyone who follows you should remember the time of the nazis...they have done bad things and all people thought they are doing good, same thing as like you today!!!!!!

Loading...

Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more