DAY 28: PIZZA MONTH 2007 - TOTONNO'S

LOCATION: Totonno's (26th Street and 2nd Avenue, NYC)

GUEST(S): Robin Rothman

ORDER: half of a small Margherita/Bianca

PIZZA REPORT: Half Margherita, half Bianca (white) - what a cool pizza! Sure, a little of the sauce oozed over into the Bianca side but Totonno's sauce is delicious. The golden brown coal fired brick oven cruster surrounded the pie like a ring of freshly baked Italian bread. It's light but sturdy, sturdy yet chewy. How do they do it? I suspect magic.

ATMOSPHERE: Totes Totonno's! If they needed an ad campaign, that might be what they use, but, thankfully, they do not. Although the Kips Bay Totonno's franchise is slightly more expensive ($18-24 w/ tax and tip, no alcohol) than the no-frills Coney Island original, the taste of the signature coal-fired brick oven pizza is nearly identical. There is also more seating, season decoration, and televisions than the original. Go at off peak times and you'll have the whole restaurant, bar, and nice music to yourself. It is slightly off the beaten path but it's totes worth the trip.

VERDICT: 4 out of 5

MISC:
1. There is a debate as to whether Anthony "Totonno" Pero or Gennaro Lombardi opened the first pizzeria in America. Although both began making pizza in 1905, Totonno did not establish his pizzeria until 1924. I like 'em both.
2. Robin Rothman and I watched what turned out to be the final game of world series. If you still don't know who won, the video clip may have a spoiler.

Category:

Entertainment

Tags:

• Totonno's
• Kips
• Bay
• Coney
• Island
• Robin
• Rothman
• Boston
• Red
• Sox
• Pizza
• Month
• Sean
• Taylor

[sweenykim]

Go out to the Coney Totonno's! It's so Yummy!

[spotlightsean]

See my comment above. Thanks.

[staretheinfant]

Original location or it didn't happen.

(...Or so I've read.)

[spotlightsean]

See my comment above, which points to my comment above that :). Thanks!

[LoveSublime40]

thanks now I want pizza! *drooling*

[spotlightsean]

I just re-watched it and I feel the same way. Yummy! Thanks for the comment.

[foodstooge]

The COney Island place re-opened in March 2010. The same thin crust as DiFara's (Ave J & E. 15 St, Midwood), but without the chaotic slow service, nearly-double prices, and lack of parking. You Do have to buy a full pie at Totonno's, so better bring 1 guest. There is an excellent thin crust place in Staten Island. "Pier 76," 1 block from the Ferry, offers the same cardboard crust, but only $2.40 slice, and No need to buy a full pie.

[spotlightsean]

Yeah, I have been to the no-frills Coney Island location several times...just not during Pizza Month (October).  I tried to go this past October but they had not yet re-opened since the fire. Thanks for your comment!

[darthbrooklyn]

If youre going to go to Totonnos, you have to go to the one in Coney Island... there is no substitute...