think short answer 2 dilema 3 lots of things bout traveler and other patients would need to be taken into account and alot would need 2 be known bout the situations nd the potential impact, to make a justified decision the surgeon would need alot of power to delve into relations and the lifes of thos ppl involvd directly/indirectly, such power would most like lead to curruption and i think the curruption it could caus awhole far out weigh benefits of case. nly god shud hav that sort of power.
3 like other dilema's in respect of trading life to sav several, in 3 the travelers own morality could be taken into consideration, think if traveler has gd morality nd sensibility would choose 2 die 2 sav ovas nd if not tht cals into question wat sort of life he livin nd sort of person he is, i think it wud b immoral 2 operate witout consultin travelr, think real moral dilema is whethr doc shud hav right to overrule travelers decision which i think violates ethics etc. gods job must b hard lol
nobody will push the fat man because nobody ever saw a fat man stopping a trolley , nobody believes it can happen
niinja2 9 months ago
think short answer 2 dilema 3 lots of things bout traveler and other patients would need to be taken into account and alot would need 2 be known bout the situations nd the potential impact, to make a justified decision the surgeon would need alot of power to delve into relations and the lifes of thos ppl involvd directly/indirectly, such power would most like lead to curruption and i think the curruption it could caus awhole far out weigh benefits of case. nly god shud hav that sort of power.
johnnyw00t 1 year ago
3 like other dilema's in respect of trading life to sav several, in 3 the travelers own morality could be taken into consideration, think if traveler has gd morality nd sensibility would choose 2 die 2 sav ovas nd if not tht cals into question wat sort of life he livin nd sort of person he is, i think it wud b immoral 2 operate witout consultin travelr, think real moral dilema is whethr doc shud hav right to overrule travelers decision which i think violates ethics etc. gods job must b hard lol
johnnyw00t 1 year ago
why would you push the fat man though?
elphiegreen 2 years ago
That said, I personally would push the fat man (though not on the premise that he's fat).
Obversity 2 years ago
Oh, sorry, I completely misread your proposition. Somehow. I'm not sure how, now that I read it again.
Obversity 2 years ago
most people would treat an obese man differently because of his weight. most people are stupid and descriminate
elphiegreen 2 years ago
"most people are stupid..."
Explain to me how that is a "stupid" mindset.
Obversity 2 years ago
Well my answer was clever too! Look!
-:)
Mrmoc7 3 years ago
clever clever clever!
Great questions :]
Braindiscovering 3 years ago