The Real Vocal Quality Battle : Jaclyn Victor vs Siti Nurhaliza

who has the most powerful vocal??!!
you decide!

Category:

Music

Tags:

• The
• Real
• Vocal
• Quality
• Battle
• Jaclyn
• Victor
• Siti
• Nurhaliza
• Malaysia
• Best
• Asian
• Idol
• Voice
• of
• Asia
• Malaysian
• Ikon
• Asean

[areistida89]

@eastwest2010 dik, sy jawab soalan mr.chantique kat atas tu. "who has the most powerful vocal?"....and i decided, its jac. dare u deny the fact? sbb mll timelink yg saya bagi, bukan snang nak jerit mike duduk hampir setengah meter dr mulut tp still dengar jelas suare die....tak ada plk saya cakap siti x bagus nyanyi pun. dia pun mmg no.1 n still, kan. dan itu mmg satu lg fact, undeniable.

[eastwest2010]

@areistida89 jac mmg ade suare power, tp suare die x versatile.. siti mungkin xleh buat mcm 2.13 tp jac boleh ke buat mcm 2.32...? siti mungkin xleh nyanyi gemilang se-power jac, tp jac pon xkn boleh nyanyi nirmala sehebat siti... extra utk siti, siti da buktikn die leh nyanyi pelbagai jenis lagu.. jac biler lagi..??

[areistida89]

of course la jac! tak tengok ke 2:13 tu mcm mana? haha

[lildevillain]

Definitely Siti. Jac's voice is powerful but it sounded quite monotonous to me. And she can't sing many types of songs. Siti's voice is melodious and she can sing almost all types of songs. This is only a view. No offense.

[azmiphd]

DCT nyanyi ada jiwa...

[aquablueemerald]

you can't compare this both singer la... they are not in the same category of voice... its like comparing apples and oranges...

[Pkin93]

seriously, jac menyanyi menjerit. whereas, Datuk Siti Nurhaliza menyanyi dengan nada yang betul.

[razzikhilaf]

sedap sangat lenggok siti time dia nak tukar ke lagu purnama merindu.. kat 2.18...

bukan senang ye nak buat cmtuh..

[sweettinta]

they both are great singers ...but i still choose siti as the best.... coz she can sing any type of song ...and every song that she sing will always become a beautiful song... really enjoy it.

[WannIsmailNaqiuddin]

Both great! 

[claus49]

I love both of them. I just think Jac and Siti shouldn't be placed on the same scale. They are too different, one is power house. The other one is rather like a silky smooth stream. soft and gentle and yet still can be powerful.

[sentaphatimaknok]

video compare cm sial...

[eastwest2010]

Siti will never can sing like Jac, because Jac's voice is higher and powerful... BUT Jac will never ever can sing mesmerizingly, melodious, smooth, versatile and dynamic like the one and only, Dato' Siti Nurhaliza.. The Voice of Asia..

[sutramaya]

xleh nk banding ..jac ada gaya tersendiri..ct pun sama..tp my personal opinion, vocal siti lebihh dinamik berbanding jac...jac pula powerful dengan key yg tinggi..siti punya key agak limited tp siti berjaya mempelbagaikan gaya suara nya...

[sekadi]

@SyamsuddinFaruok stuju.. siti ngan jac vokal yang TAK BOLEH kalau nak dibandingkan macam ni.. sbb tu susah kalau depa dua ni nak diduet sekali.. bayangkan lagu siti dinyanyikan stail jaclyn,mesti sakit telinga lagu2 tu. bayangkan lagu jaclyn dinyanyikan oleh siti.. mesti dah jadi stail lain dah.. they are who they are.. don't change them

[SyamsuddinFaruok]

this thing is pointless. to actually compare singers' vocals is a super weirdo, immature, psychotic thing to do.