Bernadette Peters - "Rose's Turn" - 2003 Broadway Preview
Uploader Comments (DivaBehavior)
Top Comments
-
@victoriaindigo Mendes has a different take on the musical material he directs. He most definitely has it in his bones. I saw Mendes' "Gypsy"...I was 13, and it was a totally mesmerizing experience.
Oh, and Laurents should validate Peters; it was his idea to cast her in the first place. Early on, LuPone expressed interest in playing Rose in this revival, and Sam Mendes was, apparently, somewhat interested in her, but Laurents forbid it.
I loved both revivals, though. 2003, and 2008.
Video Responses
All Comments (124)
-
How could you say Rosalind Russell and Bernadette Peters were horrible? Russell is one of the greater actors of our time, and Peter who was superb. Pity you think that way.
-
@DivaBehavior Hey they were all good! THey all had a different version of Rose. BTW This is supposed to be Rose's psychotic break song. The point of the song is to show her slowly deteriorating character and not an elegant song by any means
-
can't believe she lost the Tony to Maria Jarret Winokur! 4:40 and on is FANTASTIC!!
-
@ythc11 i am, for sure!
-
@ythc11 yes
-
@ythc11 i'm definitely interested in seeing the entire performance. bernadette is my favorite Broadway performer.
-
I have this vid if anyone is interested
-
@DivaBehavior I'm just curious- did you actually see Merman as Rose? Unfortunately I didn't, but everyone I've spoken to who actually saw Ms. Merman live said that she was NOT the ham that revisionists have labeled her. There are a few audio clips of Merman live as Rose, and, from what I've heard, I think that her acting was the most real, and the least overacted. Maybe you should check them out.
-
@victoriaindigo But, have you seen anything Mendes has directed (on stage)?
-
It should be noted that Peters, singing sick here, sings the final section a semitone lower than Merman did. That is practically unheard of. Every other "Rose's Turn" I've heard since Merman ended at least a whole step lower. Brava Bernadette!
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Bernadette is shite in this role. There, I Said it!!! Patti is amazing in this role; Read ARTHUR LAURENTS' new book: Mainly on Directing - then you'll know all the shit that both Laurents and LuPone went through; and all the useless time and effort that didn't go into Sam Mendes' pathetic revival of Gypsy (2003) above with Ms Peters who was worse than Rosalind Russell in the 1962 film version of the show.
fountainchain126 1 year ago
@fountainchain126
Rosalind Russell was a magnificent Rose -- She can actually *act,* unlike many of the self-indulgent histrionic hams (Midler, Merman, and sometimes Lupone) who just over-act everything for the sake of getting a laugh.
Bernadette is a brilliant actress. She was still very sick during this preview, and probably should not have been performing at the time, but she still did.
Mendes is a great director, but his "Gypsy" was a bit sloppy. Still, Bernadette nailed it.
DivaBehavior 1 year ago 19