What Did The Ref See In Disallowed US goal vs Slovenia?

To the left of the melee and right in front of the referee Dempsey pushes the defender with his hand into a couple of other players, freeing him up to run in behind the defender unchallenged. This appears to be what the referee saw, but no confirmation however. The whistle blows early before Edu puts the ball in the net.

My verdict: off the ball infringements by both sides, so could have gone either way. but push right in front of referee makes it easiest to call. US fortunate to play with all 11 men for full 90 minutes after Dempsey elbow in 1st minute, just unfortunate on this occassion.

Possibly pertinent point - decision comes off the back of this report :

http://www.goal.com/en-india/news/140/world-cup-2010/2010/06/15/1977790/world...

WORLD CUP 2010: GABRIEL HEINZE'S ARGENTINA STRIKE SHOULD HAVE BEEN DISALLOWED - FIFA
Referee's committee criticise Wolfgang Stark's decision not to give a foul for Walter Samuel's obstruction in the build-up to the goal.

By Daniel Edwards
15-Jun-2010 6:38:00 PM

Argentina missed several gilt-edged chances on their way to a 1-0 reverse of Nigeria on Saturday. However, according to FIFA the one attack that did finish with the net bulging should have been disallowed by referee Wolfgang Stark.

Ole reports that a FIFA post-match analysis ruled that there was a foul in the build-up to Gabriel Heinze's stunning header, and that Stark should never have allowed the goal.

The FIFA referees' committee released their findings on Tuesday, as a guide for future judgements in this year's tournament. And amongst other rulings, they made it clear to referees that they must watch for infractions at corners and free-kicks - specifically attacking players blocking markers, as happened on Saturday.

As Juan Sebastian Veron's cross floated over Walter, Samuel enveloped Chinedu Obasi and stopped him from moving, thereby giving Heinze all the space he needed to propel the ball home. Stark should have therefore penalised Samuel for obstruction and awarded a free-kick to the Super Eagles - a judgement that could have changed the course of the whole game for Argentina.

Although the ruling comes too late for Nigeria, it has interesting implications for the rest of the tournament; a sign that FIFA will not tolerate the pushing, shoving and holding commonplace on both sides at dead-ball situations, and that in future such offences will be punished with either disallowed goals or penalties in the case of the defence committing an infraction.

Category:

Sports

Tags:

• slovenia
• usa
• ref
• disallowed
• goal