Will Madden 2012 Have The Same Immersive And Authentic Gameplay As NFL 2k5?

Strange as it seems and sad as it is, are we actually looking at a 7 year old game built on a last gen console that replicates football better than Madden 2011, possibly 12.

Just a handful of examples that shows the subtle realism 2k put in its products. While it inst without flaw or game play issues, it certainly shows much more attention to detail than EA's Madden series.

Category:

Gaming

Tags:

• All
• Pro
• Football
• 2k8
• 2k5
• EA
• sports
• NFL
• Videogames
• Truth
• Chaser
• Tak
• Online
• Franchise
• Co-op
• apexisfree
• Gideon
• Prime
• Team
• Builder
• Running
• Animation
• Madden
• 10
• 04
• 09
• 11
• Konsole
• Kingz
• PS3
• PS2
• Xbox
• 360
• IIan
• Cummings
• E3
• G4
• IGN
• Gametrailers
• Rob
• Donald
• Back
• Breaker
• Backbreaker
• video
• game
• gaming

[shadowdrinkerx]

I guess I could compare the hit detection in the original Mario Bros to that of Galaxy 2...

It'd make about as much sense.

[RyanMoody21]

@shadowdrinkerx Are you saying comparing two football games doesn't make sense, they are in the genre unlike your choices.

Rather than guess about what you could do, how about you actually make some videos? Seriously, last video you said I manipulated game play and I guess now you want to talk about points of comparison.

I don't expect anybody to agree with me on every point, but if your going to be overly critical of the content, its time to put down the key board and pick up the camera.

[RyanMoody21]

@MissDeeCole Working on my own, which I plan on releasing for download.

[TheSnapPrince]

Still got my copy. Madden is waaayyyy too arcade-y. Too many morphs and warps. Rocket catching rarely happens in 2k5 and in real life, when it does it requires PERFECT positioning.

[DontHateMe225]

2K5 Years later and still the best EA just does not give a fuck about the players and they dont care about the NFL they just picsj ther shit out because they know they have the license and frankly im sick of it

[Jpalomino90]

Best NFL football game I have EVER played in my life from the customized stadium music to the first person football mode....

[sawink]

I have said since 07, every year that, There will NEVER be another 2K Football NFL game EVER. EA would Lise a fortune and didn't they hire or break up the entire 2K football studio??? I recall that EA hired a lot of the 2K staff...which proves more they were not interested in greatly or decently improving Madden on a yearly basis. You can listen to the EA NHL team which states, "We dont have the sales of Madden. We need to drastically improve our game every year." you can listen and read them

[sawink]

This is also a 2005 games, produced in 2004 for the 2K5 season! So, that's 7 years ago. Plus, Old Gen technology and didn't have 7 years of (better than Madden sales and support from the NFL and sponsors) So, imagine after the progression of 2K5-a hypothetical 2K12 now and Next Gen.plus current upgrades in HD TVs and controllers...the game would be unbelievable...not just have added 3D GRASS!!!! EA pulled of a Great Business move. EA isn't to blame its the No Fun League...NFL

[rpcriojas]

Imagine the potential of this game in 2013 when the EA exclusive license expires. By then im not afraid to say the game could be near perfect simulation.

[Camel5hark]

Does anyone care?

[newj34]

Maybe we should just bring NFL 2K football back. Then we could let madden continue to evolve into something other that football.

[Joeyland]

It will not, its a fact

football principals do not apply to Madden, they do somewhat in 2K

[Joeyland]

It will not, its a fact