Part 1 Murtaza Khan vs Usama Hasan / Music Debate

Music in Islam debate held at the London Muslim Centre , Ustadh Murtaza Khan vs Mr Usama Hasan

Many issues are discussed suring this debate such

- Musical instruments (halal or haram?)

- Women singing and dancing in front of men

- Fatawa regarding singing and instruments from classical ulama

Category:

Education

Tags:

• music
• nasheed
• murtaza
• khan
• vs
• usama
• hasan
• london
• muslim
• centre
• sami
• yusuf
• outlandish
• islam
• channel
• dawud
• wharnsby
• ali
• global
• peace
• and
• unity
• radical
• middle
• way
• amir
• sulaiman
• amr
• khaled
• al
• qardawi
• muhammad
• zahra
• sufi
• hamza
• zaid
• shakir
• hadra
• yvonne
• ridley
• the
• end
• of
• kamal
• mekki
• sufism
• ghina
• imam
• ghazali
• ghazzali
• tariqa
• tahir
• ul
• qadri
• لشيخ
• محمد
• حسان
• tassawuf
• shia
• fosis
• lsbuisoc
• londonisoc
• masjid
• tawhid
• suhaib
• native
• deen
• murabitun
• samiyusufofficial
• awakeningrecords
• 786
• brother
• dash

[NightSurgeon09]

Why are muslims putting so much emphasis on Music!? There are bigger consernes for the Muslim community to consider (dawa, helping the poor, educating non muslims on what ismal is realy abou). Yet we are at each other's throats over MUSIC? We could be channeling our energy into helping people kick drugs and instead spend all this time arguing over music? This is nonsense.

[Aimanonline]

@NightSurgeon09 it is because some people try to make halal what Allah and his messenger made haram , i,e music

[iamhassam]

This event was possibly the most horrendous "islamic" event i've ever attended

Felt physically sick at the jeering and mocking that took place (mostly off stage)

The description says " Ustadh Murtaza Khan vs Mr Usama Hasan" how ridiculous... people here are calling Usama Hasan a Kafir, even accusing him of drinking alcohol?! SubhnaAllah

Murtaza Khan described Usama as "our honourable brother & Sheikh in his own right" (just listen to the first 2 minutes of this video)

may Allah forigve us all

[Aimanonline]

@iamhassam Ever thought of why young muslims would dislike him? Instaed of just feeling sick without knowing. Of course I dont call him a kafir but he certainly is a devaint heretic

[israelifaggot]

i am a muslim and i admit shamefully i listen to music, but i would NEVER try to change the deen to conform with my own whims and desires. that is perverse. i know what i do is wrong, but what would be infinetly worse is trying to change the deen of Allah (swt). This Usama Hassan has no common sense. Once you move away from literal Islam, what do you have left, nothing. You can then do what you want with religion, you can argue we do not have to pay zakat anymore or pray anymore.

[s333mus]

mashala always use text from the quran and hadith. i always enjoy his lectures

[ItchesMybutt]

We Should Not Shrug Off Minor Sins, As They Make Way For Major Sins.



[Tuntaalam]

@NightSurgeon09

Ibn Al-Qayyim "Never do the love of song and the love of Qur`ân come together in a person’s heart except that one expels the other." (Madârij Al-Sâlikîn, Vol.1 p487) now tell me its not important.

[iamhassam]

@Aimanonline My brother, it's pretty basic fiqh that the any such accusations must be substantiated by the accuser. Please read (4 parts - Google "suhaib webb takfir") an article outlining some of these principals.

[Aimanonline]

@iamhassam maybe you could clarify for me why he isn't a deviant heretic?

[iamhassam]

@Aimanonline can you clarify then when you said "I dont call him a kafir but he certainly is a devaint heretic"

[TheMuslimBro]

Mashallah Murtaza Khan Knows what he's talking about, Alhamdulillah i think the truth prevailed in this debate

[CriterionProductions]

Assalamualikum

Please check out the below video and forward it to friends and family. Also check out my other videos.

Please leave a comment.

youtube.com/user/CriterionProd­uctions#g/c/E1434EF6153F66A3

[mu5lim]

@iamhassam Bottom line, Usama 'Babboon' Hasan has shown his true colours, speaking about muslims like the kuffaar speak about them. And now the monkey has been exposed and several scholars have exposed his kufr beliefs.