Also I'm actually quite surprised that my brass burke dented a little from just putting it in my backpack (albeit with a lot of stuff inside to begin with, especially my hard flute case). But I myself have started to be a bit unsatisfied with the tone and response so I've went back to my generation brass. Every generation I've owned worked extremely well.
@hawkboymh I've never owned a composite whistle, only the brass session. However the note I got was hearing from others on the chiff and fipple forum. If it doesn't break when dropped, I guess then they aren't as fragile as I thought, but they are still quite weak being just Bakelite and fibre. So, do refrain from applying too much force to such whistles as a precaution.
@deterdettol I've been playing Burke composites, narrow bore, session bore and low D for years. All have been dropped several times with no problem. I stepped on the low D by mistake after one too many beers. No problems. Anything that would break these would bend a brass whistle. Your statement about sound and weight is spot on. Maybe your experience with fragility is different. Did this actually happen to you or are you speculating?
Too bad that a post designed to separate sounds, you use such a cruddy microphone, record at a distorted level, and have some kind of squirrel-cage sound underneath it all, along with some kind of continuous.thumping.
I prefer Al whistle frankly.
DeafFret 6 months ago
can you do a do a video demoing some of the MK whistles. I am really interested in one but videos are scarce
gtrplr42 6 months ago
Also I'm actually quite surprised that my brass burke dented a little from just putting it in my backpack (albeit with a lot of stuff inside to begin with, especially my hard flute case). But I myself have started to be a bit unsatisfied with the tone and response so I've went back to my generation brass. Every generation I've owned worked extremely well.
deterdettol 1 year ago
@hawkboymh I've never owned a composite whistle, only the brass session. However the note I got was hearing from others on the chiff and fipple forum. If it doesn't break when dropped, I guess then they aren't as fragile as I thought, but they are still quite weak being just Bakelite and fibre. So, do refrain from applying too much force to such whistles as a precaution.
deterdettol 1 year ago
@deterdettol I've been playing Burke composites, narrow bore, session bore and low D for years. All have been dropped several times with no problem. I stepped on the low D by mistake after one too many beers. No problems. Anything that would break these would bend a brass whistle. Your statement about sound and weight is spot on. Maybe your experience with fragility is different. Did this actually happen to you or are you speculating?
hawkboymh 1 year ago
@clflover is yours the session type? i'm thinking of getting one, but i heard that the high B needs lots of air.. do you find that to be the case?
chansherly212 1 year ago
Too bad that a post designed to separate sounds, you use such a cruddy microphone, record at a distorted level, and have some kind of squirrel-cage sound underneath it all, along with some kind of continuous.thumping.
Rajamuttu 1 year ago
Caution:
The composite material gives Burke's whistles made from the material a tone similar to whistles made from wood, and makes the whistles light-weight.
However, if dropped or sat upon the whistle may shatter as the material is fragile.
If you want to buy a Burke whistle made from the composite, please make sure you keep your whistle safe.
deterdettol 2 years ago
The composite makes me smile.
Sounds like a wooden whistle
right out of the days of legend.
Thanks for posting this.
shas1814 2 years ago
Brass Burke is definitely my choice. Playing it for 4 years now and still in love.
clflover 2 years ago