Sirah/Prophet Muhamamd and the killing of Ka'ab bin Al Ashraf

Ka'ab bin Al Ashraf
Speaker:Dr:Bashar Shala.

Dr. Bashar Shala is a cardiologist and lecturer on Islamic history and law. He graduated from the Faculty of Medicine (University of Aleppo, Syria) in 1990 and has been in the profession for 17 years. He currently practices Cardiology, Internal Medicine, and Interventional Cardiology in Memphis, Tennessee.
http://www.understanding-islam.com/related/text.aspx?type=rarticle&raid=2...
http://www.answering-christianity.com/sami_zaatri/rebuttal_to_silas_2.htm

- Ruling on one who insults the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him)

http://islamqa.info/en/ref/22809
مقتل كعب بن الأشراف بالعربي:
http://rasoulallah.net/v2/document.aspx?lang=ar&doc=3595
احترام الرسول عليه الصلاة والسلام
http://www.qurancomplex.org/Quran/tafseer/Tafseer.asp?l=arb&t=Saady&n...

Category:

People & Blogs

Tags:

• Answering
• ISLAM
• Christianity
• jews
• zionists
• madina
• macca
• arab
• qurish
• SHARIA
• SUICIDE
• QURAN
• MUHAMMAD
• KORAN
• JIHAD
• TERROR
• Kuffar
• Kafir
• TERRORISM
• WAR
• NAME
• ALLAH
• MOHAMMAD
• HIJAB
• HIZB
• TAHRIR
• مقتل
• كعب
• بن
• الاشراف
• المدينة
• خيبر
• MUSTAFA
• KEMAL
• ATATÜRK
• LAIKLIK
• ISLAMIC
• MO
• Muslims
• Islamization
• Islamisation
• Islamophobia
• women
• feminism
• Ummat
• al
• Western
• Islamofascism
• Nazi
• AhamdsQuran5
• Yathrib
• Banu
• Kinuka
• Qaynuqa
• Kinka
• sam
• shamoun
• Christian
• prince
• investigateislam
• david
• wood
• murder
• of

[mohandispak]

the subject is covered in 6 verses 4:51-56.. clearly Allah has taken the punishment of such people as His own responsibility, you mentioned only v51 see also v55

you also said jews accepted the assasination of Kaab by not retaliating, jews never retaliated openly

see how our prophet dealt with defaulter like Bani Qaniqa after Batle of Ahzaab and Quresh after conquest of Mecca

see also return of Akrama while treaty of Hudaibiya was only drafted

Our prophet never ordered any extra-judicial killing

[IslamResponses]

@mohandispak

The Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) sometimes chose to

forgive those who had insulted him, and sometimes he ordered that they should

be executed, if that served a greater purpose.

I would rather go with the scholars .all of them agree that the story had happened and the hadith is authentic but you depend on your opinion and have no proofs to support your claims .again my references are in the description section.

[IslamResponses]

@mohandispak

is false or fabricated or it is from shia sources as you claimed before and all you did is keep repeating the same argument which is already been explained in this lecture and in the description section there are many other references about it and about the punishment for those who insult the prophet or wage war against him and broke the treaty .

so prove to me the hadith is false and i am willing to take this video down .

[IslamResponses]

@mohandispak

Again you showed disrespect for prophet Muhamamd in this comment as well then you claim falsely that i claimed so, i asked u many times to not call the prophet as you call your boyfriend and always say peace be upon him after his name or at least say the prophet of Islam.

Haven't you read :(Make not the calling of the messenger among you as your calling one of another.) verse 24:26

now you put words in my mouth subhan Allah

I asked u to prove to me that this hadith is false as

[mohandispak]

@IslamResponses how did you anticipate I do not respect my prophet..

consider me non muslim and do not divert the topic, this is easy for you; people who challenge you, you expel them outside the circle of Islam; but in reality it doesnt matter at all

you said Muhammad agreed to a proposal of deceiving Ka'ab in order to get him killed..?

I know Muhammad who was Sadiq and Ammen

Tricking the enemy and deceiving the enemy are two different things

[IslamResponses]

@mohandispak

A real Muslim respect prophet Muhammad peace be upon him and do not call him only with his name, he is not your boyfriend .You did not post a question , all you did is just claiming the hadith is false without providing any evidence to support your claim . this lecture and the links in the description section are more than enough to refute your repeated argument . and again the hadith is not a shia hadith .

stop arguing for the sake of arguing and read more about this topic .

[mohandispak]

@IslamResponses Allahuma Salle ala Muhammad wa ala alehi wa sallam

I have a limitation of 800 charactoers on youtube

What you have to do if I am a Muslim or not, you just consider a non-Muslim is asking you an ethical question

I am talking with fact, you answer it

you want to tell people that our prophet tricked non-combatants get them killed?. what you call war-trick is actually charector faliure

Perhaps you know some other Muhammad

Most hadeith in SihaSitta are false fabricated

[IslamResponses]

@mohandispak

I think i wrote the speaker in this video is( Dr.Bashar Shala ) not me.

you claimed the hadith if false without any proof , u should mention why it is false ?

i have many articles in the description section as well about the same topic , check them .

according to islamqa website :

[IslamResponses]

@mohandispak

This comment has nothing to do this lecture and again, When you mention the name of prophet Muhamamd peace be upon him , respect him and say at least Prophet muhamamd or the prophet of Islam (whether you are a muslim as you claim or not )

[mohandispak]

Battle Badyr; Muhammad arranged his army in a way that smaller number looked bigger

Battle Mauta; Khalid bin Walid staged a drama to pretend receiving fresh reinforcement, romans disengaged and Muslims withdraw

Such tricks look good on Muhammad and his companions

But trick like calling enemy for negotiations in a way to dis-arm him and then kill him with deception does not suit our prophet

This Hadith is totally fabricated to de-fame our prophet Muhammad 'Sadiq wal Ameen'