What does Traditional Mean?
Uploader Comments (DrTzeus)
All Comments (62)
-
By inner rotation, I meant specifically that move done at the beginning. Not of course the all other rotations present in the rest of the form. But still, I don't like this addition as in the form. Thanks for the details anyway.
-
This is only the arms and stepping portion of this exercise. It progresses to having kick counters as well. However, kicking requires you to stand in one place on a single leg, and thus you have lost mobility. So we generally do not kick first, but we do kick a kicker, or jam into them to rob their base.
Keep in mind this is a drill and not free sparring.
-
I see much regarding tradition and telling others their oppinion..last I checked we are not Han we do however do our best to honor their sacrifices and ways of combat.We are however born in modern day America and seeing how Di-Si-Gung Ting is still Head instructore at the V.T gym in Hong Kong take it up with him. He may slap you around a bit....lol....we just do the best we can with what we have guys like it or not.Good job Si-Hing Jeff
-
The tone of your comments imply that even Si-Gung Moy Yat did not invent any training programs but only repeated what he was taught. or that Uncle Yip taught only one way to all his students. I can not believe this. Things grow.
two snails, a mountain, 10,000 years....all things are possible.
-
The Anti-Grappling Program is indeed a modern invention using the movements and principles of WT. It is clearly taught as such and thus is not part of the classical program. While _ing _un has grappling, sweeps, counters to throws and can even be used if put on the ground, the training programs we use are new.
Latosa Escrima is not required but provides actual weapons systems from a culture that uses them.
-
WT is based on a core philosophy and is always checked against that. We do not even trust that our Sifu is getting it perfect, we are taught to check everything ourselves.
Uncle Yip did this with what he was taught in China and what he learned from Leung Bik or that he developed himself as his understanding grew.
Only if you blindly trust tradition will it get weak with every generation.
No inner rotation in the beginning of the form as you show it at 1:23 . Check Ip Man's videos. Crossed arms are very dangerous as they are very easy to block to jam you. Like at 2:07, he could easily jam you and unbalance you after. This first move of the form is both arms going up, but an application of this can be using one arm going up with that angle to get rid of wrist grappling for example. Your inner rotation is even against wing chun principles as it takes time and is a complex movement.
Nikoo033 2 years ago
@Nikoo033 Nice comment and I appreciate it. Thanks.
Leung Ting claims he added Kwan sau himself to the first movement, as it is as you say in other styles. However, I disagree with notion that inner rotation is against WC principles. It is in many places in the forms, even in chain punching.
You even know in application this is done as a single move and I show it as split rotation at 2:26
They are linked only to act as a guide for learning kwan sau along centerline, just as for Tan and gaun.
DrTzeus 2 years ago
do you have any application videos?
domite1 3 years ago
I have some planned and some film but nothing edited yet.
DrTzeus 3 years ago