Deep Space nine Vs Voyager

A fair and unbiased examination of star trek series DS9 and Voyager to determine which is better. comments and choices welcome

Category:

Entertainment

Tags:

• star
• trek
• DS9
• deep
• face-off
• sci-fi
• space
• nine
• voyager
• TNG
• the
• next
• generation
• borg
• dominion
• farscape
• benny
• hill
• vs
• sg1

[Hero87]

LOL funny comparison especially the face palm of Janeway at the end.

I haven't seen DS9 but I have seen all of Voyager multiple times and love it. I just ordered the DS9 complete dvd boxset and can't wait to start watching it now if its suppose to be better than voyager plus it looks like it was made at the same time. Compared to TNG which looks horribly dated.

[badgerboyUK]

@Hero87 words fail me, what are you like 10 years old?

[parrot998]

For the people who constantly attack DS9 for not being about exploration, it was. It was about exploring humanity for what it is, without any idealist rubbish getting in the way of making that point. People are flawed, and DS9 is the only Star Trek show that made flawed characters, but didn't condemn them as bad guys for it. I will admit the seventh season strayed from that idea, but it was a consistent theme throughout the series.

[SiLL88]

Part IV

DS9 is in deed far superiors over voyager. Now that does not mean that one hast to be more stupid or one has to lack “sophisticated” taste to lake Voyager over DS9, it is a mere observation of the complexity and the effort gone into making the show worthwhile (and yes, in this aspect Voyager clearly looses, even though fans of the show will have a hard time to admit it). Simply put: Voyager is a world of simple relations and well... unbelievable characters.

[Hero87]

@badgerboyUK Its true TNG does look really dated. Just look at the bridge and the holodeck when its turned off. Compare that to Voyager and DS9. Also when the Enterprise D fires its phasers the phaser beams just magically appear from the ship. There is no detail, can't see the phaser banks etc, it just seems so fake. Maybe back in the day when it first aired it would have been okay but now its pretty much unwatchable. Anyhoo this is just my opinion. Im not saying that the story of TNG isn't good

[robaralis]

you have to give Voyager a fair chance. it really starts to get great after the 3rd season when we encounter the Borg and Seven of Nine comes to the show. . the bridge episodes from season 2 to 3, and also 3 to 4 are superb with lots of action. Deep Space Nine is probably better but Voyager is still friggin great. The Doctor is easily one of the greatest characters throughout the entire franchise!

[babyMx3]

@miloootic aaaahh, i see. i thought you were just dissing on ds9. and im like, its not that bad. but yeah, this vid is pretty bad. i do like ds9 better, but voyager is still a good show.

[miloootic]

@babyMx3 im not taking this too personal i enjoyed all trek series and a fan of ds9.im mad coz this vid is disgusting.

[babyMx3]

@miloootic get over myself!? get over yourself, your the one trying to convince everyone that your right, and that ds9 sucks. well im sorry buddy, but we're all entitled to our own opinion. and its just a bloody tv show. your obviously taking it too personal. time to get a life i think.

[miloootic]

@babyMx3 oh pls learn how to spell???im not English get over yourself.they won the freaking war,despite them saying repeatedly the amount of casualties they were sitting in their seats and blowing up every ship.ask any actor/director you know, what he thinks of O'Brien/sisko acting,you'll get what i mean.the increased tonality,the way they talk and stall words it was just humiliating for an actor to be that fake.

[babyMx3]

@miloootic Any person with an iq above 50 would learn how to spell properly. And by the end of ds9, everyone went their own ways. Friends were seperated, sisko left jake, odo and kira were also seperated. i wouldn't exactly call that happy. and how are obrien and sisko the worst actors ever?

[miloootic]

@babyMx3 yes sure but that means nothing,any person with an iq above 50 would have to say that obrien/sisko were the worst actors ever...evrything they say and do from season 1 till the end is just plain fake. happy ending??? how is ds9 not a happy ending?