(Rare!) Saint-Saens Plays His "Marche Francaise" (1919)
Uploader Comments (transformingArt)
Top Comments
-
does anyone know if saint saens wrote down this version?
-
I enjoyed this very much. Thanks for posting it.
All Comments (21)
-
@MelosAntropon Sometimes the case, but this is a 12-inch side, ample room for the piece as usually performed. Menuhin was asked in the '70s if the faster tempi in his recording of the Elgar Concerto under the composer compared with many "modern" performances were imposed on them by the 78 sides and he answered emphatically no. They could have all the time and as many sides as they wanted but it was the way Elgar wanted it to go.
-
Good clues to the interpretation of his music: don't dawdle! He makes no concessions to age here, dropped or wrong notes be damned. Wish we had him in some Beethoven.
-
@paopaomanalansan Are you referring to Faure's piano four hand arrangement of all four movements of the Suite Algerienne, including this movement? It is excellent! I own a copy.
-
@Rlaw2222 There is an outstanding arrangement for concert band. See our recent video on You Tube at nocbclarinetchoir. Hank
-
In response to the person asking if this was ever written down, I am not sure where you can get it but I do own a copy of this piano score. I found it in an old music store near the back of one of the stacks of scores and it is fairly old. I can get you more info on it but I will have to dig it out of my records as I have it safely stored.
-
@MelosAntropon That argument is sometimes right. But we know that Saint-Saens preferred fast tempi. Arthur Rubinstein recalls hearing him playing the Chopin E major Scherzo (I paraphrase) "much too fast, but very clean". His recording of parts of the Second Concerto are pretty close to the tempo we play today. Busoni's mad dash for the finish in the Liszt HR 13 is often cited as an example, but I own a copy of the disc, and there definitely is "room" for a more cautiously played conclusion.
-
Thanks for posting this historic recording.
-
LOVELY! TY transformingArt for posting.
I was going to post this, but I see you beat me to it!
Very nice!
1926VictorCredenza 1 month ago
@1926VictorCredenza It would be better if you can still post this version as well - maybe your copy would sound better than this?
transformingArt 1 month ago