Al Jazeera: Debate between a liberal and an islamist in Egypt.
Top Comments
All Comments (381)
-
@ISMASHYOUBRO :: So you mean those verses are not relevant for today?? isn't quran valid anywhere and everywhere?? maybe you should tell me the context because a far as I know from the Sirah and Tafasir thoses verses were responsible for the ethnic cleansing of non-muslim from the arab penisula - maybe there arre other reasons maybe you can let me know instead of salivating xD
-
@ISMASHYOUBRO spent*
-
"Arabic is my native language and I can understand Quran and Hadith very well."
Qur'anic arabic is a different animal. That's like me saying I know English, therefore I can understand Shakespeare and other plays very well(which can be untrue due to the nature of language presented in those plays.) Imam Sha'afi(RA) spend 1/3 of his life perfecting his skills in understanding the rich nature of Classical Arabic.
Again read WHY these verses were revealed.
-
@NicknameYotube Lol, I was salivating at hearing you quote these verses. Can you tell me sir, in what context these verses...actually Surah Tauba itself was revealed? All of these harsh commandments are for a reason. Look it up.
-
@ISMASHYOUBRO I do not need neither R. Spencer neither G. Wilder to understand Islam, Arabic is my native language and I can understand Quran and Hadith very well. Let's talk about "the minor Tax" what tax is paid in submission and humiliation as the verse sais ::9:27::? do u really believe yourself? the jizya's aim was to humiliate the unbelievers with Islam and there is countless hadith that proves my claim. you are the one who have to get his head out of lying scholars
-
@ISMASHYOUBRO :: your replies shows extreme ignorance about Islam ::9:5:: But when the forbidden months are past, then fight and slay the Pagans wherever ye find them, and seize them, beleaguer them, and lie in wait for them in every stratagem (of war); you know what the forbidden month are?? means no war - the quetion is what war allow you to kick out unbelievers from their home land only bcuz they dnt believe in islam?
-
@NicknameYotube 'just like Islam, you r ordered to kill unbeliver wherever you find them unless they follow islam or pay the Jizya'
.......Really...Really? Really. I'm rather insulted you posit such an argument. Those verses pertaining to killing unbelievers are in the context of war and war only. Jizya is just a minor tax the non-Muslims must pay on a yearly basis. It's distributed to the poor and so forth.
Please take your head out of Robert Spencer/Geert Wilders garbage.
-
@ISMASHYOUBRO Nazism is based on a racist ideology just like Islam, you r ordered to kill unbeliver wherever you find them unless they follow islam or pay the Jizya
Nazism was murdering people because of their race, Islam is for their beliefs
Islam aloows you to rape slave girls captured in war even if they were married and its a quranic verse and the shit goes on u just have to wake up.
regards
-
@NicknameYotube Islam is a comprehensive way of life that covers all of its aspects, in the private and public spheres of life. Comparing it to Nazism and Fascism? Yeah, way to undermine your credibility.
It felt good to here the liberal say at he end: you are completely insane, go away.
The arab world need many more people like him.
snoken112 5 months ago 14
"This man uses filthy and nauseating language. To hell with him."
WIN :D
llKeon 2 months ago 3