IL
Upload

Loading icon Loading...

This video is unavailable.

3 Minute Philosophy - St. Thomas Aquinas (without anti-Catholic bias and fallacies)

Sign in to YouTube

Sign in with your Google Account (YouTube, Google+, Gmail, Orkut, Picasa, or Chrome) to like Greg Aitchison's video.

Sign in to YouTube

Sign in with your Google Account (YouTube, Google+, Gmail, Orkut, Picasa, or Chrome) to dislike Greg Aitchison's video.

Sign in to YouTube

Sign in with your Google Account (YouTube, Google+, Gmail, Orkut, Picasa, or Chrome) to add Greg Aitchison's video to your playlist.

Uploaded on Apr 16, 2010

The original "3 Minute Philosophy" video on St. Thomas Aquinas has some very obvious anti-Catholic bias and rather misleading fallacies within it. This is the same video but with a few of the unnecessary scenes/comments deleted from it. If you are a Religious Educator or just someone who wants the good qualities of this video (without the Catholic bashing), here you go.

If you are interested in some rebuttals to the original 3 Minute Philosophy video, please see below. These are my comments sent to the creator of the original:

--

A good video, funny too, but with some obvious anti-Catholic bias (surprise, surprise, someone else decided to jump on the lets bash the Catholic Church train!) and deceptive misunderstandings. For instance:

1. Random and unnecessary plug about pedophilia, as if pedophilia only occurred in the Catholic Church (Ever look at public school teacher stats on this? The Catholic Church's rate of pedophilia absolutely pales in comparison, but I certainly haven't seen bigotry and intolerance directed at them for this.)

2. Suggesting that Thomas' reasoning was biased because he already believed in the existence of God: "Being a Catholic monk its not surprising which answer he leaned towards". If you use this line of reasoning than you also better not trust any other intelligent theist who contributed something to world (i.e. Einstein, Newton, Copernicus, and the original proposer of the Big Bang Theory, Fr. Georges Lemaître, to name a few).

3. Suggesting that Thomas believed Aristotle was being tortured in Hell for not being Catholic, which is something that neither Thomas or the Catholic Church taught/teaches (Note: Dante's Inferno suggested that Aristotle and other virtuous pagans would be in a state of limbo, but it is important to remember that a number of Dante's depictions do not line up with Catholic teaching and the Church has never fully backed Dante's understanding of Hell).

4. Suggesting this was the first time the Catholic Church could argue against atheists (Ever heard of St. Augustine or any other Doctors of the Church that lived before Thomas Aquinas???)

5. Suggesting there are some components of Catholic doctrine that do not make any rational sense no matter how hard Thomas Aquinas tried and that Thomas' only answer to this was there are some things you just have to take God's word for. It is true that Thomas says, "It is impossible to attain to the knowledge of the Trinity by natural reason" (Question 32, Summa Theologica), but this in no way insinuates that Thomas thought this makes no rational sense. He was pointing to the fact that the notion of the Trinity could not be achieved by natural reason alone and that we could only know of it were first revealed to us (divine revelation).

6. Suggesting that the reason Thomas Aquinas was made a saint was because the Catholic Church loved him so much. On the contrary, the reason he (and all other Catholic saints) was made a saint was because of his love for God and the holiness he showed throughout his life. Sainthood is not primarily based on popularity or intellect, but on holiness (which Thomas certainly possessed).

For further info on proofs for God's existence, please see http://www.peterkreeft.com/.

Specifically see:
1. 20 Arguments for the Existence of God: http://www.peterkreeft.com/topics-mor...
2. Audio talks #8, 18, 23: http://www.peterkreeft.com/audio.htm

-------------

  • Category

  • License

    Standard YouTube License

Loading icon Loading...

Loading icon Loading...

Loading icon Loading...

The interactive transcript could not be loaded.

Loading icon Loading...

Loading icon Loading...

Ratings have been disabled for this video.
Rating is available when the video has been rented.
This feature is not available right now. Please try again later.

All Comments

Comments are disabled for this video.
Loading...
Working...
to add this to Watch Later

Add to