REVIEW - Urban Decay Liquid Eyeliner

I just thought that I had to share my opinion on this product, because I consider the twenty bucks spent on it to be a waste and didn't want anyone else to be disappointed.

Lesson here - don't always get what you pay for ;-(

SWATCHES - In Order from top to bottom:
L'Oreal Telescopic Liquid Liner
L'Oreal Lineur Intense
Revlon Colorstay Liquid Liner
Maybelline Ultra Liner Waterproof
Urban Decay Liquid Liner

Category:

Howto & Style

Tags:

• urban
• decay
• eyeliner
• fail
• review
• swatches

[MarJoTV]

Very helpful. Could u tell me which ones have brush tips or hard sponge tips I can only seem to apply with brush tips. By the way have you tried from Target the Jemma Kidd liquid liners they are great even impossible to remove and come in awesome colors but about $16. I'd love to know what you think. Thanks.

[jubilee1two3]

@MarJoTV let me see, the maybelline one that stays on so well has a very thin brush tip. i will have to try the jemma kidd liner, i have been eye-balling her line for a while ;-) thank you hun!

[karinajhn]

thank you so much! you helped alot:)think ima buy the telescopic one or the maybelline:)

[jubilee1two3]

@karinajhn you're very welcome, thank you for watching ;-) i also can't recommend the L'Oreal Lineur Intense enough, i love it's applicator best for some reason ;-)

[88asianchick]

I want the thinnest liquid eyeliner.can you please tell me which product is the best?

[jubilee1two3]

@88asianchick the waterproof maybelline one in the video makes a very thin line, i would recommend any liner with a brush tip for the thinnest line ;-)

[msalidarose]

i wish you tested the waterproofness of them since my eyes water really bad throughout the day! =[

[mrsbronze]

Your review was very helpful and I love your accent. I find more and more that these HOT cosmetic companies are selling us cheap products with cheap ingredients. But because we buy them from department stores....we are deluded n2 thinking that we are getting the best (fill n the blank) out there. Honest reviews like yours point out the flaws that busy moms like myself would not have the time to investigate. Thank you!

[drmrls1]

Could you please do a review on the best eye liner pencils... Most seem to smudge or are too dry to put on... thanks

[drmrls1]

That's a very helpful review, a comparison... this is exactly what i'm looking for, which is the best liquid eyeliner that doesn't smudge! Thank you!

[iloveapplejuiice]

Thankyou!! :) 

[vahsvideo]

ive had my bottle for a year and its still easy to open and close, mine doesnt smear at ALL allll day (mostly cause i dont rub my eyes like that?)

[sleepingexplorer]

I agree with you on the packaging (UD's old tube-style was better), however, I've never had smearing/smudging problems with this eyeliner. it just plain doesn't move, crack, smear or flake all day on me. Best black eyeliner I've ever used, and that's saying a lot. for me it's a must-have in Roach and Smog as well.. they're flattering, non-boring neutrals.

[PumpUpTheGlitter]

ive been living by this eyeliner for about 4 months now. i thought it was good until i purchase the lineur intense eyeliner in carbon black.. its soooo much better and it cost about 8 bucks. compare to the urban decay eyeliner i got from sephora for 20 bucks..the urban decay has like a greyish look to it compared to the loreal liner. its not horrible .. like i said ive been using it for 4 months and loving it , but compared to the loreal its crap. the loreal is so much easier to use & cost less!