PLANT HOMEOPATHY Part 1

Using Skype John Benneth interviews London based plant homeopath Vaikunthanath das Kaviraj.

Category:

Science & Technology

Tags:

• agriculture
• homeopathy
• gardening
• for
• farm
• and
• garden
• plants
• agro
• plant
• kaviraj
• vaikunthanath
• das
• pesticides
• fertilizer
• atheism
• agnosticism
• how
• works
• botany

[ysiblini]

Wonderful, thank you for the enlightenment

[den151redbank]

This is great. I'm passing it on to my horticultural friends.

Thanks !!!

[sleepcity]

@Bandershot As usual I find it nearly impossible to follow your rambling. All I can parse is that you have a serious persecution complex and no understanding of really introductory science. But by all means...keep on truckin' John. Can't wait to catch more of your vitally important videos about Farrah Fawcett!

[Bandershot]

@sleepcity Sounds like you've described your approach exactly. Repeatedly I find the same fallacies from anti homeopathy, such as the claim there are no double blind studies. Would you bet on it? Every argument from you reduces to ad hominem from straw man. You certainly don't have any attribution for your assertions, you won't even say who you are, typical of ani homeopaths; once proven wrong on one assertion, you seem to think you remain credible on the rest. Try me. Use your real name.

[sleepcity]

@Bandershot John are you familiar with what an ad hominem argument is? Are you familiar with the argument from authority? Are you familiar with the pharma shill gambit?

If you reject double-blinded, placebo-controlled studies as a sound method of confirming the efficacy of substances, well...you have no right to pretend that you know more about pharmacology and medicine than the consensus of all of the world's researchers (I'm talking about the ones with degrees from, you know, real colleges).

[Bandershot]

@sleepcity Yeah, I see plenty wrong with your response. You're not addressing anything ad rem. Once the simple, testable premise has been put forward, that plants react to the dilutes used in homeopathy, the only ad rem left for you is to test it with your holy double blind. But you're not going to do that, because it threatens your basic assumption that dilutes have no intrinsic force.. So what you & the rest of your ilk are left to do is anonymously engage in endless character assassination.

[sleepcity]

@Bandershot 1) Ad hominem -- I only want to know how great I am. 2) Argument from authority. I am asking questions and 3) I'm critical of this nonsense therefore I'm a paid YouTube agent of pharmaceutical companies (ad hominem). 4) Kaviraj has written books -- argument from authority. 5) More and more ad hominem attacks.

See any problems with this response of yours, Mr. Benneth?

[Bandershot]

@sleepcity If its so important for us to know who & how great you are, why are you using a pseudonym & trying to insult someone who's presenting a subject you have no experience with? Why aren't you asking questions about this topic instead of posing & ranting like a paid shill? Kaviraj is the author of a book on how to use homeopathic substances on plants. Why should that inspire your hatred? You feeling guilty about something? What's wrong with you? Aren't they paying you enough in ER?

[jackp6]

@sleepcity

it's your problem that you have studied I suppose... I experience not through study

[sleepcity]

@jackp6 Um...have you just learned that your body is made of salt and water? I work in hospital emergency rooms and teach physiology to college students. Perhaps you can drop the spiritual mumbo-jumbo BS and sign up read a VERY BASIC introductory book on human physiology? Might blow your mind and lead to less public ridicule in YouTube comments...