IJ on the Individual Mandate
Sign in to YouTube
Sign in to YouTube
Sign in to YouTube
Uploaded on Feb 23, 2012
Listen to an in-depth podcast about this subject here: http://ij.org/freedomcast/4336-mutual...
If government-mandated health insurance is upheld by the U.S. Supreme Court after the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (PPACA) case is argued in March 2012, the Institute for Justice warns in its amicus brief that there will be dire and predictable threats to individual liberty and voluntary relations that have been the foundation of American contract law for centuries.
Constitutional law professor Elizabeth Price Foley, who is the executive director of the Institute's Florida Chapter and who co-authored IJ's brief, said, "The individual mandate violates a cardinal rule of contract law—to be enforceable, all agreements must be voluntary. The Framers understood this, and would never have given the federal government the power to force individuals into lifelong contracts of insurance. The Court should not allow the government to exercise this unprecedented and dangerous power."
As IJ's brief shows, the principle of mutual assent, under which both parties must consent for a contract to be valid, is a fundamental principle of contract law that was well understood during the Founding era and is still a cornerstone of contract law today. Indeed, contracts entered under duress have long been held to be invalid. Yet the mandate forces individuals to enter into contracts of insurance that would never be valid under this longstanding principle. (For a copy of IJ's brief, visit: www.ij.org/PPACAbrief.)
If the U.S. Supreme Court fails to strike down the individual mandate, there will be nothing to stop Congress from forcing people into other contracts against their will—employment contracts or union membership, for example. If we still have a constitutional republic in which the federal government's powers are limited, then the Court should strike down this law.
The Institute for Justice's brief is the only amicus brief filed with the Court that examines this case in the context of the history of contract law. The brief illustrates how the Supreme Court has recognized the principle of consent in commercial relations in its Commerce Clause and Tenth Amendment cases, and it explains why the U.S. Supreme Court has a key role in acting as a check against this unconstitutional power grab by the federal government.
Standard YouTube License
- 10:56 Supreme Court, Obamacare, Individual Mandate and the Constitutionby HowTheWorldWorks Featured 13,161
- 3:00 SUPER PACs: Occupy the Courts, Colbert & the Fight for Free Speechby InstituteForJustice3,682 views
- 3:57 How are food truck entrepreneurs like the Buffalo Bills? They're unrelenting underdogs & dreamers.by InstituteForJustice5,880 views
- 1:56 Can the Government Make Entrepreneurs Do Useless Things For No Reason?by InstituteForJustice20,442 views
- 10:00 California Redevelopment Agencies Abused Their Powers & Should Never Returnby InstituteForJustice5,873 views
- 44:40 Clarence Thomas: Supreme Court Nomination Hearings from PBS NewsHour and EMK Instituteby EMKInstitute23,494 views
- 8:59 Judge Napolitano: "Individual Mandate Most Bizarre Tax in the History of the Country"by TheLeakSource13,264 views
- 1:06:06 Sovereign Freeman Gordon Hall Pt 3 of 17 on Contracts, Law, Court, Judgementsby VerifiedNews5,479 views
- 6:31 Pelosi taken apart by David Gregory on false Obamacare promisesby Washington Free Beacon322,505 views
- 10:06 Wheat, Weed, and ObamaCare: How the Commerce Clause Made Congress All-Powerfulby ReasonTV71,731 views
- 6:04 The Great Gibson Guitar Raid: Months Later, Still No Charges Filedby ReasonTV110,574 views
- 10:47 22. Contracts: Duressby Aaron Dewald1,675 views
- 6:43 Why Obama's Healthcare Mandate Will Failby Stefan Molyneux10,539 views
- 44:46 Bob Poole and Adrian Moore: Why Highways Beat High-Speed Railby ReasonTV7,050 views
- 4:30 Why Obamacare Was Ruled Unconstitutionalby Battlefield315101,780 views
- 3:19 The Healthcare Arguments - OyezToday Special Featureby oyeztoday1,633 views
- 7:24 Glenn Beck Video Of Anita Dunn: Mao Tse Tung "Favorite Philosopher"by Speakmymind0256,252 views
- 7:59 A VOTERS' GUIDE TO REPUBLICANSby BillWhittleChannel290,759 views
- 1:24:16 Panel: Whose Constitution? The People, Political Movements, and the Courtsby RWUEDU400 views
- 23:48 Elizabeth Price Foley Discusses the Tea Party Movementby catoinstitutevideo1,766 views
- Loading more suggestions...