Felicia Day On Penny's Fate in Dr. Horrible - Comic-Con 2008

NPH and Felicia comment on Joss' love of death.

Category:

Entertainment

Tags:

• joss
• whedon
• neil
• patrick
• harris
• comic
• con
• 2008
• felicia
• day

[KonFoozed]

If Penny came back it would completely ruin the massive impact the ending had. Joss knows this and won't just magic her back up just for fan service.

[BlueLint]

Penny is always being underated by her peers. She in her own rights is a super hero, advocate for the homless. To cover all the possible donation locations, she created Penny bots. It's plain to see that when her bot was exposed to Capn. hammers 'feelings' for her on stage, she being a bot and not understanding these things backed away and even off stage. The Penny killed in that sceen was only one of her many Penny bots.The real Penny was at a homeless shetler 1/2 mile away serving soup.

[xlonglostlotrelf]

@BlueLint that is an interesting POV....:D I like it! haha I never saw it like that before.

[vjm3]

@mynameismatt2010:

What does common sense and rationale have to do with sweet zombie revenge!?

[mynameismatt2010]

@YugSihtTsuj Hammer is the only one at fault for her death.

[CRolandE]

I've always thought that to bring Penny back just make it where she was the one watching Dr. Horrible do his thing for Bad Horse and the death was just faked. That she is actually part of the Evil League of Evil. I mean, how else did the ELE know whether he he was succeeding or not and she always seemed to be right there wherever he was.

[YugSihtTsuj]

If I had a choice, I'd have Zombie Penny turn up, seeking revenge against Horrible and Hammer both -- since they're equally to blame for her death.

[JetBlackNero]

@MasaruKato82 I think anything can be done in a script if you add logical boundaries. like IE, time travel = time paradoxes. cloning = nuclear power needed which is obviously dangerous. Personally I think cloning penny, who comes back evil, is a possible, and rather creative idea. good penny is evil. Maybe she starts hanging out with the ELE and Dr horrible wonders why he did it, conflict, etc etc. And perhaps the end is maybe he turns good to make sure she doesnt hurt anyone.

[JetBlackNero]

@89Altair same dealio as stephen king. they get you emotionally invested in a character and kill em off, coz it means you'll watch it hoping they come back somehow. sometimes they bring em back but usually not.

[lNOlLifeGaming]

does anyone need anything made moist or slightly dampened?

[forensic2010mnr]

@TruthBringer14 @pookagirl666 I loved reading your comments. Loving your ideas, especially having Seth Green as Johnny Snow.

[SamauraiRippeR]

@TruthBringer14 @pookagirl666 These are great ideas! Maybe Snow will be trying to make up for what he did in the graphic novel. Didn't he accidentally use an Ice Beam to freeze the city's water pieline or something?