068-The Quran: where are the five prayers listed?

Muslims know they are to pray five times a day. It is one of the five 'pillars' of Islam (Salat). They believe the five prayers come from the Qur'an itself, but they have never investigated it. Watch as Jay brings up this question at Speaker's Corner, concerning where the 'five' prayers originated, to a Muslim who has brought his ladder alongside Jay, to heckle him. The Muslim is caught off guard and is not able to answer his question at all, remonstrating that it is from Muhammad that we get the prayers. Jay shows that there are only three prayers listed in the Qur'an, and in order to find the five prayers, one has to go all the way to Al-Bukhari, who was writing in the 9th century, a good 220-240 years later. This is therefore a 9th century construct, and not an injunction which came from Muhammad at all. The Muslims in the crowd are justifiably angry and loud in this video!

Category:

Education

Tags:

• Jay
• Smith
• Muhammad
• Qur'an
• five
• prayer
• prayers
• salat
• Bukari
• Bukhari
• al-Bukhari
• Salat
• Speakers
• Corner
• debate
• discussion
• Islam
• Christianity
• abrogation

[watchful38]

Thanks Jay! I must read the Koran re the number of daily prayers for Muslims. Were not Moses & Christ both Muslims teaching Islam Both the Jews & Christians rejected Islam and changed the Old and New Testaments. So Jews and Christians are apostates and worthy of Death. A retired Catholic priest in Canada.

[izlamiztruth]

llol , stupid christian deceiver , the hadith were not written 300 years after the prophet muhammed , they were collected in a book form

[ajishso]

@imprezatuner Ha ha you think YOUtube is a big thing..

ya its a big thing in ur PAKISTHAN... not in INDIA..Anyway i cant speak more ..Because the now the whole world know that what is PAKISTHANIS and what is ur PISSLAM ..

GO TO HELL WITH UR PROPHET MUHAMMAD....

[ajishso]

@imprezatuner I FUCK UR MOTHER AND SISTER..ANYWAY I LIKE SISTERS PUSSY..COW DRINKER IS UR PROPHET MUHAMMAD..GO TO HELL WITH UR FALSE PROPHET... FUCK UUUUUUUUU

[ajishso]

@imprezatuner YOU bastard illeterate MUSLIM..Every people(christian,jew,hindu, budhist) know that u PORKISTHANI MUSLIM PIGS are living in the 7th century with ur CHILD RAPIST PROFIT MUHAMMAD.. Everyone know that with ur dirty PISSLAM u fuckers cant live in this modern world.. Still this modern day u assholes dont have electricity and railway.. Anyway our country provide much better food in here..But still USA provide food for this porkisthani MUSLIM BEGGERS..poor people..HA HA HAAA

[imprezatuner]

@ajishso im surprised to see that a low life,poor , cow piss drinker thinks himself to be a part of civilised world and now have courage to comment on youtube. Get the fuck out of that smelly internet cafe (ofcourse you dont have internet at home) , and try to earn some fucking bread for tonight's dinner for your fucking family of 10.  fucking hopeless bastard!!!

[ajishso]

U BOTH BASTERDS IF U WANT TO PRAY UR GOD THEN GO TO UR CHURCH/MOSQUE AND PRAY.WHY U PEOPLE BARKING ON THE STREET..CULTURE LESS PEOPLE..

[MzNadiaNoor]

this jay dude is annoying.. i hate to listen to him.. but i do like to listen to the subject..

[zohaib1210]

We do have speakers and very good ones might i add. Who do not use the loudness or the emotions of their voices to prove a point. Rather they acquire knowledge and use reasoning as an arguement. Christians most of them, are full of emotions which they cannot contain. You go to one of these speechs and they will say Jesus loves you and the crowd without thinking about it will just go crazy. The reason being becoz its said to appeal to your emotions so tht you just throw your brain out the window.

[boliussa]

@zohaib1210

yeah right, if you had a muslim that could speak like that you'd be praising your master!