American Idol 4/23/08 Carly Smithson Eliminated

American Idol Wednesday Night 4/23/08 Carly Smithson was elminated.

Category:

Entertainment

Tags:

• american
• idol
• 4/23/08
• april
• 23rd
• carly
• voted
• off
• fox
• paula
• simon
• cowell

[USA0806]

What the hell!! Are we deaf America?? Jason Castro is still in and Carly is gone!! That's just crazy! Carly should be in the Top 3.

[trazyt]

Full heartedly agreeee!!!

[FeetAppreciation]

very neet

[trazyt]

Thanks!

[ouano]

America got it wrong for choosing the ONE who forgot the lyrics, restarts the song and makes horrible performances to stay longer in the competition than Carly who gives 180% of her talent in every song that she performs.

[aguitarhero97]

carly shouldnt have gone. brooke or jason shouldve gone instead. i still cant believe she got voted off!

[stevenidol]

@billy29211

she came in 6th.

[billy29211]

WHAT PLACE DID SHE GET?

[tuttmasterc]

the thing is simon cowell hates irish people pure and simple. Every year on the xfactor I'm sure there are quite a few good irish singers but like british t.v love doing they show all the rejects that are irish which give us a bad name

[BlingyDamon3]

i dont think the judges should decide i think they were a major problem this year. Randy was very obviously on the payroll of archie's dad cuz he constantly critized everyone else and praised him beyond belief when he DIDNT DESERVE IT! Simon didnt help much either, always trying to find some way to push Carly down. The real solution is make the voting age 18. and maybe only able to vote like once or twice. then the real talent will win. Carly is amazing and is at least my idol this year.

[mungolee]

totally agree with you. carly was the best female by far...i even think alania who was in top 24 was one of the better ones aswell.

judges should defo decide. not sure if brooke should have got that far though

[qg6ff]

she definitely won me over. i didn't like her really in the beginning of the competition just because she was so hyped and seemed so fixed and cus of the past deals and stuff, that it was hard to like her. i tried by watching videos of her interviews when i found out she made top 24, then by top 20 i really got to liking her. i realized she's just as human, new, and fresh to this stuff as anyone else. she most certainly should go do something out there!

[emabee28]

I know, I can't believe that she's gone. she should have been top three at LEAST

[dsgoldenhorse]

that is not fair she is way better than jason,syesha.she should have at least stayed until the top 3 she was one of the best prrformers.brook white should have stayed until the top 4.me personaly i think the judges should decide who should be eliminated and who should stay because most of the people are picking for hottness and cuteness and not thinking about the voice if its good or not.so i think carly should have stayed.

[KaixRei24]

I seriously want to smack the producers of this show. The Top 3 SHOULD have been Carly and the two Davids, amirite?

Especially after Brooke pulled that redo stunt.

Carly, release another CD. I'll buy it.