Why "God is a Logical Being" Arguments Fail

In this video, I discuss my response to the oft repeated, at least in my experience, god is a logical being counter-argument.

Category:

People & Blogs

Tags:

• atheist
• atheism
• god
• gods
• discussion
• theism
• theist
• argument
• fsm
• imaginary
• friends
• friend
• being
• beings
• wisdom
• funny
• hurf
• durf
• Christianity
• Islam
• Judaism
• vlog
• blog
• video
• log
• lol

[soulf2]

Is that a bong on the top shelf?

[SolRosenberg84]

Yes, several.

[theprodigy2186]

@SolRosenberg84

I'm a theist. (more specifically panentheist)

And yet again I completely agree with one of your videos.

I am contemplating making a video response to you and trying to get a debate between you and I started...

I think we'd ACTUALLY come to some kind of an agreement... Which would through people for a loop...

Wuddo ya think?

[SolRosenberg84]

Sure, why not.

[TruthBeyond]

It's the same for saying evolution is flawed. Even if it is flawed, it doesn't prove any deity exists. It just proves that we don't know how we got here.

[Trinivalts]

@MrPathanStyle Wow, I didn't being skeptic and critical equals arrogance. I really don't see how chemical engineering exactly gives you any advantage about discussing god. You maybe made your statements clear, but that doesn't make them right. You simply believe that certain complexity = god/creationism. That's a common belief and there's nothing sort of a proof there.

[MrPathanStyle]

@Trinivalts

You are spreading your religion by trying to make fun of Theists. Yes im very uneducated, im very stupid, im wrong and you are right in every point. Happy now? Im studying chemical engineering right now and I have a full background of physics. Now believe me or not, I dont care. But I made my statements very clear. But if you simply DONT WANT TO understand, then I cant help you. If you remove your arrogance, then God will guide you :)

[Trinivalts]

@MrPathanStyle It seems you have no education yourself, you probably have no idea whats a scientific method, if you did, you would call your assertions arguments or proofs. And how am i spreading any religion?

[MrPathanStyle]

@Trinivalts

I think ur one of those Atheists claiming to have a PhD in science while they dont even know the basics of science. I have put several arguments and the only thing your trying to say is 'ur wrong and Im right', thats exactly what atheists say about theists, lol. Hypocrisy? I wont waste my time with low educated and arrogant ppl. Go and spread your religion to other ppl

[Trinivalts]

@MrPathanStyle lol, you just getting more and more ridiculous. What arguments?, you have none, just random assertions, where's your evidence, especially since you're mentioning science and saying there's no reference frame for god, lol. Do even understand what your talking about at this point?

[MrPathanStyle]

@Trinivalts

I see all the time ur just expressing your opinion instead of trying to counter my arguments. And furthermore, a God being absolute simply means he has no frame of reference, do u have some basic knowledge of science?

[Trinivalts]

@MrPathanStyle You're putting yourself in some kind of discriminatory box, so you have a position from which you can defend against, which isn't the case. You can believe anything you want as long as that doesn't mess up the already pretty much messed-up society. It's not like there's some crazy ideas behind atheism, which dictate ill morals. Most atheists and atheists in general are usually pretty non-deviant people. And god is absolute? I have no idea what does that even mean.

[MrPathanStyle]

@Trinivalts

You know what I mean by lifestyle. I simply mean that your moral values has roots towards Atheism. You are enforcing me indeed because I have to adjust myself to your standards and definitions. Why u dont like it when we preach something 'wrong'. After you die, you dont go anywhere anyway, so leave us alone. Furthermore, I have already explained that God is absolute. I gave you all the information. Now its up to you to also recieve this information in your mind instead of closing it.

[Trinivalts]

@MrPathanStyle lol, I don't enforce anything, I don't care what you follow as long as you don't contribute to spreading bad ideas (religions, cults w/e) and really you're putting into atheism way more than there is, it's not a liftestyle, lol, look it up. It's simple and it's true, because it's essentially nothing absolute, it's not a pozitive claim. And what my statements about god?, I didn't make any, you did, and making any isn't really logical, cuz you don't know if god is and/or how it is.

[MrPathanStyle]

@Trinivalts

Yes im speaking nonsense. Tipically what Atheist do and claim. When you argue against them because you dont agree with them, then you are either illogical, speaking nonsense, funny or simply stupid. And then I must accept that Atheists are very intelligent. Your statements about God has no logical background and neither this video. If your definition of 'logic' and 'proof' has no room for God and spirituality. Then you should not enforce me to follow your dogmatic way of life :)