Block v Grubel debate part 1

No description available.

• Category

  Education

[CLibrtrn]

Walter Block replies: I don't think I fully understand what you're saying, and, until and unless I do, I can't respond to it.

[jibbi4one]

Anarcho-cap weaken fair property rights law.

If the property owner is an apartment building and the owner under suspicious passive negligence (incentive to collect insurance funds) to obstruct firefighters from extinguishing blaze resulting in death, injury & destruction of tenant property. The plaintiff would lose since this means the burden-of -proof would shift to defendant. The case would be dismissed in favor of the defendant (building owner). That's not fair law.

[stealthswimmer]

Strawman. If the fire were endangering the lives and property of the neighbors property rights come into play and negotiation needs to occur because he's imposing a cost on a 3rd party.

[jibbi4one]

anarcho-caps (Block) R impractical.

Case in point: If a private property owner & nefarious set fire decides it's an advantage to let his/her property burn down 2 ground 2 collect insurance preventing fire department from putting out blaze endangering the lives and property of the neighbors (community).

Does this act make it legal?

Of course not!

IT'S ILLEGAL TO SET MALICE FIRES & PREVENT FIREMEN FROM DOING THEIR WORK TO PUT OUT BLAZE.

You can't benefit from a PUBLIC SERVICE if it's BAD!