Jordin Sparks - I Who Have Nothing

Jordin Sparks' song on American Idol 2007 edition. I Who Have Nothing original singer is Shirley Bassey.

Category:

Music

Tags:

• jordan
• jordin
• sparks
• nothing
• american
• idol
• 2007

[LadyTsun]

Although I like Jordin and she is really talented.

HALEY'S VERSION is wayyyy better, there's drama in there and the feelings is there!

ITS AMAZING!

[AjTazz1]

Stop comparing performances, Jordan has more power in her voice even if hailey's dramatic performace was better to some you... It doesnt matter, Jordan WON her season!!

[LookingAtYouFool]

@TheChaoticQuixotic

.

*Haley

.

You really ought to spell her name right because you look foolish enough as it is.

[TBTSactor81]

@LadyTsun Drama doesn't always mean big gestures or movements...there is absolute drama and feelings in Jordin's performance. First time I watched this performance I could FEEL the goosebumps form as she sang. Don't get me wrong...Haley's performance was great too but to say that her's is better is completely wrong.

[linkmax]

No offense to Haley fans, but Jordin is way better :3

[Kjini]

@TheChaoticQuixotic Okay, I don't think you know what you're talking about. Haley doesn't scream, again, she feels the pain in the song and she interpret those feelings into a wonderful song. Haley has an amazing voice, whether she'll make it or not. That's not really relevant to her talent, by the way. The music industry today doesn't care about talent as much as they used to. It's all about money and untalented rappers.

[TheChaoticQuixotic]

@Kjini *Jordin

[TheChaoticQuixotic]

@Kjini I understand that you disagree, truly I do. Don't attempt to tell me anything about music and what it used to be. Hayley doesn't HAVE that little extra...yet. She's a little girl with a big, uncontrolled voice. She is probably not going to be a legend and people probably will NOT be talking about her years down the line. They probably won't be talking about Jording either. Hayley DID NOT do this song justice by screaming her way through it. This conversation is old and OVER!!

[Kjini]

@TheChaoticQuixotic I haven't said you're not allowed to have a fucking opinion, I tell you why I disagree with you. Deal with it. And less could be more, sure, but not by 'just singing'. For someone to reach out to the audience, it requires far, far more than that. Well, at least, it used to be, when music mattered and when artists and bands were loved for their talent and their ability to be unique, and have that 'little extra'.

[TheChaoticQuixotic]

@Kjini I'm overreacting... Less is more sometimes. Just because a person yells and wails doesn't mean they're singing well or that they're conveying emotion or that they don't sound like a dying cat. I understand that you like Hayley and that's cool. I just favor Jordin's version of the song. Again for the 50th fucking time...that's my OPINION. So back off.

[Kjini]

@TheChaoticQuixotic Jumped all over your comment?? I didn't fucking jump a thing, THAT's why I mean you're overreacting. You sound pissed and it's annoying. But BACK to the song: You said she 'simply sang'.That doesn't sound good to me at all. I can 'simply sing' and I sound like a dying cat. Haley just doesn't sing, she feels it, she's lost in the song. And that requires some hell of a talent Sparks just doesn't do that in this song, it's, as you would say, just singing.And it's not good enough

[TheChaoticQuixotic]

@Kjini You based the comment "to please people like you" on what I said? That doesn't make sense, but whatever. Don't misquote...I NEVER said that Bassey didn't have any emotion---I said she simply sang the song without all the extra BS that Hayley added. Hayley is not even in Bassey's league. The whole PMS thing...*snorts* seriously, what the fuck?. Let me also remind you that you jumped all over my comment first, so let's just agree to disagree.