Isle of Hope, Isle of Tears - The Irish Tenors
Uploader Comments (machree01)
Top Comments
-
actually Annie died in her 40ies. The grave had a marker put up on 10/10 or 10/11/08 with some family members in attendance. It was done by 2 sides of the family (Smiths and Donovans) and a Irish Center out of AZ (family was on both coasts) and Ronan was gracious enough to join us and perform the song. We also got to meet the writer, another charming and gracious man.
And yes, I know this because I was a member on the committee (Donovan side) and was there for the ceremony
-
I'm into a lot of rock music but damn I love this!
Video Responses
All Comments (159)
-
The text is so beautiful that I always gets tears in my eyes and the images of a little scared girl with hertwo little brothers' arrival in this large and confusing and slightly scary place, appears in my mind's eye. Is there anyone who can tell me, who wrote this beautiful lyric and when?
The song argued, moreover, as a typical Irish folk song by an Irish couple Sean Keane & Dolores Keane.
-
@Murrayfamilytree 17 million, God bless them all
-
the song states it closed in 1943 and that 17 million people passed threw..musta been tough for them..
-
GBA
-
I love this music. And even though I am a New Zealander, I really relate to this . My grandfather was born in Ireland, and left in 1888 to escape the poverty he was facing. I would love them to come "down under" to sing for all of us who think of Ireland as our roots. Jeng
-
For someone who loves Ireland and America both, The Irish Tenors and this song brings a person to tears, and full of hope for the future.Superb Men of Erin.
-
@Murrayfamilytree I'm pretty sure it closed earlier than 1954. My father came over in 1948 by plane at Idlewild Airport (now JFK) & he never so much as step foot on Ellis Island. Ditto for my mom who came over soon after.
-
@baguinaldo1630 Thank you for the comment and kind words
-
Beautiful song.



Beautiful! Does anyone know what orchestra this is? Thank you for posting.
adabee 10 months ago
@adabee The Sinfonia Varsovia is a Polish Orchrestra
and conducted by Frank McNamara from Ireland.
machree01 10 months ago
Where are the Tenor's singing? Ellis Island? Is that the main hall?
Murrayfamilytree 11 months ago
@Murrayfamilytree it was recorded in the Registration Hall on Ellis Island,
machree01 11 months ago
According to my American Spectrum Encyclopedia, it closed in 1954 and some 20 million passed through.
Does anyone know the exact number of people that past through Ellis Island when it closed in 1954?
Murrayfamilytree 11 months ago
@Murrayfamilytree There is more information in the description bar above and a link to ellisiland, which has a timeline on the site.
machree01 11 months ago