aikido vs jiu jistsu

...

Category:

Sports

Tags:

• martial
• arts
• aikido
• vs
• jiu
• jitsu

[kenpojujitsu3]

This is just an Aikido demo. Both guys are Aikido practitioners. The teacher wears the hakama and the student doesn't. Someone just put Aikido vs Jiu Jitsu to get a rise out of people and it worked (well done BTW). It's also funny to see people instantly taking Jiu Jitsu to mean BJJ as if that's the only form of Jiu Jitsu. Those kinds of reactions out the actual martial arts practitioners from the ones that just watch MMA and martial arts on the TV and internet.

[klah4dor]

the guy supposedly "bjj" is some cunt that they paid 5 bucks to put on a gi and roll over that aikido guy... seriously how can you call this a real contest

[DiabolusIgnis]

@gianniswow And by that I mean the following; Aikido gives you plenty of opportunities to harm your opponent, when you do what you're trained to do correctly. But you don't train to actually harm the opponent. In Krav Maga you train to do this. You punch them, stab them and kick them, whereas in Aikido you go from a strike to something resembling a dance to me. This is of course not a valid truth, as my experience of aikido is restricted to YouTube.

[DiabolusIgnis]

@gianniswow Why is it better, depending on your location? That doesn't make any sense to me. You might very well be right about aikido, but you don't base your arguments on anything. On another note, I think aikido is quite good to practice, since it does improve your health, agility and the likes, but I don't think it's brutal enough to actually work. Where in Krav Maga (damn, I love taking KM as an example...) you incapacitate your opponent, in aikido you leave harming them as an option.

[gianniswow]

@DiabolusIgnis In west europe, Russia, Ukraina, Caucasus, the best martial art is combat sambo. In America jiu jitsu, vale tudo, mma. But for me aikido good only in films... very little percent of good fighters from aikido. It's good martial art, but not complete.

[DiabolusIgnis]

@gianniswow See, now that's better =) You're basing your argument on something. I don't watch UFC or the likes, so I can't argue against that in any way. But I doubt they use only combat sambo, but something of a combination between it and others.

[gianniswow]

@DiabolusIgnis If you saw mma, can you say me the champion of ufc or strikeforce, who present aikido? From combat sambo came Fedor, Alexander Emelianenko and Serghey Kharitonov. But from aikido i don't know the fighters who can win mma match.

[DiabolusIgnis]

@BJJNathanSK8 Yes, I remember trying out Jiu jitsu a bit one day, and I noticed how much of it goes down on the ground. This, IMHO, is very bad because if facing multiple opponents, you never want to get on the ground, ever.

[BJJNathanSK8]

@DiabolusIgnis for me, I respect all martial arts, I think all very good, and each with its own personality and style, but means kimono dress, so, in my opinion, jiu jitsu wins, Why we fight a lot in the ground, which not and think of all the arts, in some only a little, but it has many arts fighting on the ground, trying hard, and we do not use force, so technically, so I think jiu jitsu wins, but no art is better than another to be honest

[DiabolusIgnis]

@gianniswow Sadly, you're wrong. Your enthusiasm for combat sambo doesn't make it any better. Prove it's better. Once more, you're basing your argument only on your own opinion, nothing else.

[gianniswow]

@DiabolusIgnis the most effective is combat sambo, but better than aikido can be boxing, wrestling, jiujitsu... Only the masters, who occupied all time of his life with aikido can win to simple boxer, wrestler or bjj. sorry for bad english

[DiabolusIgnis]

@BJJNathanSK8 Isn't kimono a dress? You didn't answer what you base your opinion on. What makes jiu jitsu better in a fight?