Delwar Hussain Saydi part 8.wmv

A critical analysis of Delwar Hussain Saydees lectures. By Shaykh Motiur Rahman.

Category:

Education

Tags:

• salafi
• saydee
• error
• motiur
• rahman

[shaafeeali]

brother, you did not answer my major two questions regarding him. can u please inform how he has become madan? i have heard in a lecture by ahl hadeeth Mufti Abdur Rouf Salafi that nobody who is not born in Medina can become Madani and this is as per Arabic dictionary. for this reason he even mentioned Moulana Hussain Ahmed Madani to be a lier and Kafir for adding Madani with his name. Can u please highlight this?

[IslamBangla]

@shaafeeali

Look brother ! You really need to go back and learn your deen properly. A person doesn't become become a kafir because he added a title on his name. This is serious deviation. You have just stated someones opinion. The shaikh has studied in madina university and thats why maybe it's added. However this isn't a serious deeny issue. you only asked one question this time !

[shaafeeali]

We should not forget the hadeeth that always the previous generation will be better then the next generation. another sign of last day is the scholars will denounce the previous scholars. I am afraid considering that.

[IslamBangla]

@shaafeeali

He did not denounce the previous scholars. Remember there are deviant scholars too who called people to deviated beliefs.

[dhumketon]

Maududi(rh) served on the Advisory Committee which prepared the scheme for the establishment of the Islamic University of Madinah and was on its Academic Council ever since the inception of the University in 1962. Yet Mr Shaykh Motiur Rahman who seems a proud student of Islamic University of Madinah says Maududi had a little knowledge of quran sunnah. Yes when i read that Maududi questioned the muttafaku alaih hadith, i didnt agree with him. But the way Mr Motiur insults Maududi is outrageous.

[IslamBangla]

@dhumketon

Brother, See what the major scholars have said about Maududi, then reply !!

[10194066]

DO you know brother you are son of bitch !!

Don't do this type of Job. Please mind your language.

[abto4eva]

This guy thinks he is really something because he went to Madina University.

Sayidi is a knowledgable person, he knows what he is tlaking about. if he learned quran and hadith that well, he shouldn't have criticized someone in public, he should've said this things personally. At least thats what I know as a Muslim. I know this guy haven't learned anything from Madina University, bcuz he was criticizing Sayid Abul A'la Moududi when he wrote Tafhimul Quran while he was in jail. He's s*******

[envyromeo]

this man is pathetic, he is better off lecturing for the betterment of the people so people can learn something from him. if he is so knowledgeable he should carry on with his own lectures instead of criticizing someone else.

[shaafeeali]

i am yet to receive answer about my previous two major points brother.

[shaafeeali]

i mentioned brother that the fatwa was given by ahl hadeeth mufti. however, people like Dr Billal Philips, Shuaib Hasan are graduated from Madina university, but they did not add Madani to their name. this time u are telling that this is not a serious deeni issue, but probably many people would say this to be a serious deeni issue like the ahl hadeeth mufti if it does not have any authority.

[shaafeeali]

I really liked his lecture initially. but when I heard that he is criticizing deobondi, tablighi, Moududi, Qadiani in the same bracket I just could not stand. how Qadiani can be compared with any of them? in his lectures he praises Saudi rulers. if he did not praise then may be I would not ask this. what is his stand on King Abudllah University of Science and Technology? or he will support coeducation now after seeing the fate of Shayikh Shatri? Did Ahmed ibn Hamble or anybody criticize like him

[IslamBangla]

@dhumketon Brother, See what the major scholars have said about Maududi, then reply !!