Alternate History - Communist Germany and Alternate World War Two

What if Hitler was accepted into art school and disbanded his political ambitions? What if, without a popular Nazi Party, the Communists took power in Germany?

Leave constructive criticism, suggestions, or Ideas in the comments please. =)

Sorry, I originally labeled Italy as "Socialist". Socialism and Fascism are polar opposites, so I apologize.

Category:

Education

Tags:

• Alternate
• History
• Germany
• Communist
• Socialist
• World
• War
• Two
• Soviet
• Union
• Iberian
• Europe
• UK
• France
• Italy
• Hitler
• Mussolini

[CrusaderKnight25]

What's the name of the song? I love it!

[SonicobbsessedR2]

@CrusaderKnight25 "In my Spirit" from the Evangelion 2.0 soundtrack watch?v=i6l_iIqrM2E

[Ahreta]

Communists would never create a "Jewish Republic" of whatever. Any communist worth his salt is strongly anti-zionist and does not support creating nation states. In fact, I'm sure the communist countries would unite based on their tendencies (democratic/authoritarian).

In addition, communists do not spread by engaging in wanton imperialism (like the countries in this video or Nazi Germany), but by instigating proletarian revolutions and possibly interfering when they do take place.

[SonicobbsessedR2]

@Ahreta Communism is mostly anti-imperialistic, but all anti-imperialism within the soviet union died when Stalin took power.

And I do admit I made mistakes.

[ListWritingMachine]

I wonder how Hitler's pictures turned out in art school.

[Sereniama]

If Hitler was accepted into art school and didn't became a Nazi, then Germany would of already been bad. If Commis take over, then who knows what would happen.

[SmashThaNaziscum]

in engl.: Ian Kershaw: Hitler 1889–1936: Hubris, (London, 1998), David Clay Large: Where ghosts walked: Munich's Road to the Third Reich (W.W. Norton, 1997)

[SmashThaNaziscum]

Source of evidence:

Ian Kershaw: Hitler 1889-1936. Stuttgart 1998, S.159 ff.; David Clay Large: Hitlers München - Aufstieg und Fall der Hauptstadt der Bewegung. München 2001,S. 159.

[SmashThaNaziscum]

Interessting thought. And one fact is also interessting, at first Hitler was active in the "Slodatenrat" (soldier-council) of the communist "Räterepublik" (Counciles-Repulic) in Munich in 1919. But then he became a counter-revolutionary, revealed two comrades, and became a Nazi. Hitler is fucking Judas Iscariot!

[SovietRussia5152]

@cilliangreene Yeh but the commies helped the Allies win the war.

[SovietRussia5152]

@ListWritingMachine Probably it was of him becoming Fuher of Germany and the Swastika in the background XD.

[MrYdraeine]

@Ahreta communst war anti zionist but Stalin was very sensible to minorty problems he was in favour of the creation of israel (but he didnt know how the things will devlop)

and he gaved lands to jewish who escaped from nazis ,im communist but i respect the jewish religion altought im anti zionist , but the meaning of all this was that stalin helped very much the jewish community and he would have been,prbably,in favour of a creation of jewish soc. republic

[AnarchoTrotskist]

@AnarchoTrotskist: L.Trotsky: "Big capital tend to visit fascist as a guy with wicked teeth tend to visit a dentist...He doesn't like that, but he will have to do that."

The fact, that in Ger., where communist movement and left-wing in general were strong(and left wing always supported internationalism, anti-rasism and solidarity) racist and reactionary nazis took power instead...was a result of stalinist ignorance. Particularly insufficient internationalism of Stalin's policy.