Top Comments
All Comments (205)
-
I don't like American Idol anymore.
-
Fair enough. I'm not going to argue with Billy Joel.
-
It is about being a musician. A lot of people can sing.
-
i agree,there is also a backlash, negative stigma to AI. lets face it, it's just not seen as very cool.
-
That's why you forget about the people that win american idol. They might be good singers, but they have no songwriting or composition talents, so they can never put out music after their 5 seconds of fame.
-
i agree i think people should pay there dues.i think it makes the artist more appreciative of there fame.
-
The only thing American idol creates are ratings. It's something most "musicians" laugh at.
-
Elvis was the best ever american idol
-
@cadmiumblue I think he SHOULD be a guest judge on American idol. He could be like "Nice voice. Now what have you written?"
-
@Monkberry50 Well said.
american idol is stupid billy joel is right
nicopico50 1 year ago 21
Also not to add any more fuel to the fire but BlingyDamon3 you do have some valid points but Billy Joel is absolutely right and unlike Ellen Degeneres he actually knows a thing or two about music. Notice he's played all over the world, he's had as someone said before 33 top 40 hits, and also he still going even into his 60s! I'd love to see clay aiken, kelly clarkson, or david cook keep going into their 60s and i'll be alive to see it, if it actually happens. which of course i highly doubt.
jacjr6193 1 year ago 5